FORTUNE -- Ever heard of EveryBlock or Village Soup? What about Backfence? Each community-focused venture launched, then folded. Many more so-called hyperlocal sites have also tried and failed. Even AOL's Patch news sites have had trouble sticking. Their struggles beg the question: Why is hyperlocal so hard?
It shouldn't be in theory, at least where news is concerned. The ongoing decline of small, local newspapers presents what seems like a significant opportunity for ventures like Patch. (Arguably, many local residents still want to stay informed on nearby goings-on.) And yet the company that AOL (AOL) CEO Tim Armstrong acquired for an estimated $7 million back in 2009 has since struggled to reach profitability. In 2011, Patch made $20 million in revenues; a former employee told Fortune that just 12 of the 863 Patch sites then were profitable. Fast-forward two years: Armstrong announced this month that 400 of Patch's 900 sites would either be shuttered or partnered off, resulting in 500 employees losing their jobs. Ouch.
Part of Patch's problem, and other previous hyperlocal efforts, has to do with way it rapidly expanded. "They went all in before they perfected the product, and in retrospect, that wasn't ideal," a former AOL executive told Fortune last year. To be fair, Armstrong has said one-third of Patch sites are already successful, while the other third will likely turn a profit. If Patch becomes largely profitable by the end of year, which Armstrong has pledged, it will have done so amid serious struggles and major changes in strategy, from having bloggers contribute content to trimming budgets across the board.
Indeed, the better approach sounds ridiculously basic but important: get the core product right first, then grow from there. Patch grew first, problem-solved later, then dealt with the fallout caused by its brash expansion. Also, different geographic areas will use a product differently, with popular content in one market being less read in another. New hyperlocal startups should be taking note of Patch's failures.
"When you start to fragment editorial into hundreds if not thousands of different sites, well, I can't think of an example that's worked," admits Nirav Tolia, CEO of Nextdoor, who admires Patch's efforts but differs on how to grow a company. Prior to Nextdoor's launch in October 2011, Tolia and his team spent a year in a pilot phase, testing out their idea of neighborhood-focused social networks, learning how they were used, and tweaking features accordingly. One of Nextdoor's first testbeds was a Menlo Park neighborhood with 150 households, a number the company believed would be the average sweet spot for all neighborhoods. But more testing proved otherwise, with each network ranging between 500 and 3,000 homes.
Two years later, Nextdoor is now available in nearly 18,000 neighborhoods in all 50 states, with users numbering in the single-digit millions, who chatter on about bikes they want to buy or last night's burglary. And according to Tolia, there isn't a place where a Nextdoor social network has not eventually grown into a local hub with between 500 and 1,000 users. Promising growth to be sure, but it's still too early to tell whether Nextdoor's viral user growth will translate into a long-term profits. Still, it is enough for Nextdoor to push up its goal of introducing new streams from 2015 to summer of next year. "Long-term we believe there's the potential to build the next yellow pages," waxed Tolia.
Outside of news, the strategy has also worked for other hyperlocal players. Yelp (YELP), the business directory and customer review site, took a similar approach and now, eight years later, trumped Wall Street estimates with $55 million in sales during the second quarter, a 69% jump year-over-year. And according to CEO Travis Kalanick, his four-year-old car-summoning app Uber is profitable in many of the 38 cities it's expanded into, a process that involves sending employees to a potential market for up to several months to study factors including local transportation systems to anticipate potential supply and demand.
Indeed, in the case of hyperlocal, the Facebook motto of moving fast and breaking things may just beg for trouble.
AOL CEO Tim Armstrong has been on a roll - and he wants to make the most of it.
FORTUNE -- To AOL CEO Tim Armstrong, Silicon Valley is a "pig pile" where every company is copying every other company. "Everyone is putting out the same services, the devices have become more commoditized, and the platforms are the same," he said Thursday during a presentation at the Paley Center for Media in MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - Mar 8, 2013 1:48 PM ET
Fortune's curated selection of newsworthy tech stories from the last 24 hours. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you every day.
"Google+ is a prime example of our complete failure to understand platforms from the very highest levels of executive leadership (hi Larry, Sergey, Eric, Vic, howdy howdy) down to the very lowest leaf workers (hey yo). We all don't get it." -- Google engineer Steve Yegge in a reportedly leaked blog post. (Silicon MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Oct 13, 2011 3:30 AM ET
At this point, the ultimate fate of the beleaguered Internet company is anybody's guess. But here are some of the executives that may get a chance at taking the top spot.
FORTUNE -- It's impossible to guess who might be Carol Bartz's replacement at Yahoo because it's impossible to guess what Yahoo might look like when a replacement is named. It could be a totally different company before a CEO is MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - Sep 8, 2011 2:39 PM ET
The CEO of the struggling firm meant to turn it into the 21st century's Disney -- a thriving, diversified media powerhouse. Now, it looks like things may not turn out that way.
FORTUNE -- Tim Armstrong, the CEO of AOL (AOL), is a romantic. That's laudable, not to mention rare in modern American business. Unfortunately, modern American investors don't look favorably on romantics if they can't bring profits along with their lofty MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - Sep 1, 2011 12:18 PM ET
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
AOL plans to layoff several hundred employees starting today in editorial and other media product groups, as well as jobs in India -- areas like network and ad sales should remain unaffected. The move comes as AOL restructures its editorial division after MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Mar 10, 2011 5:00 AM ET
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web.
The first (of three) days of Jeopardy featuring the IBM supercomputer Watson as a contestant ended in a tie. Watson and competitor Brad Rutter wrapped up the evening with $5,000 each on the scoreboard, while Ken Jennings, who had bested Watson in the much-publicized practice match, ended up with $2,000. (AllThingsD) AOL CEO Tim Armstrong invested more than $10 million in MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Feb 15, 2011 8:31 AM ET
AOL needed a traffic hub and social media know-how. HuffPo needed an exit and a new job for its visionary leader. Was merging the right answer?
As big as the Super Bowl's viewership was, the biggest news to come out of last night's festivities wasn't the Green Bay Packers' victory or even the bevy of new, pricey commercials that emerged, but the media bomb two attendees dropped right after the event. MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Feb 7, 2011 5:19 PM ET
A curated selection of the weekend's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web.
Still revved up from last night's Super Bowl shenanigans? You can relive the best parts -- or well, the commercials at least -- via YouTube's annual AdBlitz voting contest here. And if that's not enough, check out CNNMoney's excellent roundup of rejected ads for extra laughs. (YouTube and CNNMoney)JP Mangalindan, Writer - Feb 7, 2011 6:00 AM ET
A leaked presentation on its "master plan" and its abysmal earnings report only confirm that AOL needs a new way.
By Dan Mitchell, contributor
Ken Auletta's profile in The New Yorker of AOL CEO Tim Armstrong last month was a grim assessment the company's prospects and a scathing indictment of the quality of AOL's content -- much of which, Auletta wrote, is "piffle." The company, he seemed to conclude, is more likely MOREFeb 2, 2011 2:36 PM ET
|Regulators pave way for Internet "fast lane" with net neutrality rules|
|GM's $1.3 billion recall cost wipes out profit|
|Female gun instructors in hot demand|
|Apple shares soar on increased buyback|
|Premarkets:Buoyed by Apple, Facebook (but not GM)|