FORTUNE -- The promise of a digital-first education system has driven venture capital dollars into the fast-growing category of education technology startups. There are countless software portals aiming to create efficiencies in school systems and even more digital tools for streamlining the classroom. There are tutoring startups and MOOCs, or massive open online courses, that have attracted massive venture funding. And there are algebra games. Oh yes. Many, many, algebra games.
The explosion of ed-tech startups in the last five years has led many to speculate we're approaching peak ed-tech. The word "bubble" has been thrown around. Venture firms invested around $600 million into ed-tech startups in 2012, which is approximately four times as much as they did in 2002.
Meanwhile, industry observers aren't terribly excited about the most latest ed-tech innovations.
"I don't need another algebra app," said Peter Cohen, president, McGraw-Hill School Education, speaking at the recent DeSilva & Phillips Dealmakers conference in New York. "I don't need another one. Everyone in Silicon Valley thinks they've created the first algebra app ever. That's not actually the biggest problem, although algebra is a problem," he said.
Brian Napack, a senior advisor to buyout firm Providence Equity Partners, said many ed-tech companies are aiming too low. "Do they have a product that's actually a solution for someone's needs, and will the decision makers recognize that it's a problem?" he asked. "There are lots of gradebooks out there. Don't tell me you've got the first digital gradebook, and also nobody is viewing that as a problem."
The "small problem" problem isn't unique to ed-tech. Look no further than the sea of derivative photo-sharing and music apps to see how many startups' offerings start to blend together. Venture investors Mark Suster of Upfront Ventures and Chris Fralic of First Round Capital popularized the term "FNAC" to describe startups whose idea is a "feature, not a company."
Regardless, companies based around small features are particularly tempting in the education sector, which has been dominated by longstanding relationships with textbook giants, and tech stalwarts like STI Education Data Management Solutions, or Renaissance Learning, a 29-year-old company which Google's (GOOG) new private equity arm, Google Capital, just invested $40 million into. Schools are slow to adopt new technology because they have to be: Their procurement processes are inflexible and complicated, involving contracts, RFPs, lawyers, review cycles, approvals, and compliances. This makes it difficult for small startups to sell their products into schools. The procurement cycle alone lasts long enough for a startup to run out of money.
Napack said not understanding the market they're selling to is the most common mistake for ed-tech startups. Schools make complicated customers because they're not financially motivated -- their goal is to educate students, not make money.
The second-most common mistake is with a startup's go-to-market strategy. "Is their problem actually attached to a pocket of money?" Napack asked. "Occasionally [a deal] happens by Federal caveat, and then that changes, and then the companies don't have a source of revenue anymore."
Napack predicted a shakeout to the venture investment flooding education startups, but said things are different this time around. "There's a Darwinian thing that happens in ed-tech. It's survival of the fittest," he said. "But this isn't going to be like the last ed-tech bubble. We're actually going to get some real companies out of this one."
It's unclear if "real companies" will be the ones which have raised the most money. Last fall, the shortcomings of some well-funded startups had industry observers asking whether the bubble has already popped: Kno, which had raised almost $100 million from Andreessen Horowitz, First Round Capital, Floodgate, and others, sold to Intel (INTC) for just $15 million, reported Om Malik. Then Altius Education, which had raised $26.6 million, sold in an acqui-hire deal to a marketing company. And Grockit, backed by $44.7 million from Benchmark and GSV Capital, pivoted away from its initial strategy, selling its core assets to Kaplan. Tutoring startup Tutorspree also shut down last year.
Others are only beginning to figure out monetization while offering their main product for free, the so-called freemium business model. Coursera, which raised $85 million in venture backing, has experimented with selling certifications to students who complete free courses on the platform. Udacity, backed by $20 million from Andreessen Horowitz, is experimenting with sponsored courses and matching students with employers. Knewton, backed by $54 million from Founders Fund, Pearson (PSO), Accel Partners, Bessemer Venture Partners, and FirstMark Capital, is also going freemium, earning revenue with licensing fees and a premium platform for universities. Edmodo, backed by $40 million from NEA, Union Square Ventures, Greylock Partners, and Benchmark, doesn't charge teachers to use its platform, but instead sells them apps.
These well-funded companies aren't "FNAC" startups. They're trying to completely transform some aspect of education by making it free or accessible online. The only problem with that strategy is that it's just as risky as offering a boring, derivative algebra app. Except here, there's a lot more money at stake.
Google's social media technology is finally giving Facebook a run for the money. But where it may really differentiate itself is in its privacy policies.
by Kevin Kelleher, contributor
FORTUNE – In the web industry, imitation is much more than a sincere form of flattery. It's an admission of another's success, and an effort to catch up to the industry leader in hopes of surpassing them.
In social media, Facebook has been the MOREJul 12, 2011 11:00 AM ET
News Corp. will reportedly sell the early social media star at a fraction of what it paid in 2005. But the company's problems go back to its earliest days.Dan Mitchell, contributor - Jun 28, 2011 1:10 PM ET
Speakers at Brainstorm GREEN have been stopping by Fortune's virtual conference to take questions from online attendees:
Bill Weihl, Green Energy Czar, Google (GOOG)
What comments might [you] have about the "Bloom Box" replacing a National Grid?
Weihl: There's a role for both distributed generation and centralized power plants -- I expect we'll see both -- and the Bloom Box will play a part in distributed generation.
Last year Google bought a decommissioned papermill MOREApr 6, 2011 3:28 PM ET
The company learned they had to accurately account for saving money in order to understand how they profit from green investments. Once they did, the figures were staggering.
FORTUNE -- Making chemicals takes energy -- a lot of it -- so the mere fact that Dow Chemical (DOW) can save a lot of money by improving their energy efficiency is not what's surprising. It's just how much energy and cash they've MOREScott Woolley - Apr 5, 2011 11:25 AM ET
Green industries of the 21st century could spring from unlikely sources -- just ask software billionaire Tom Siebel.
FORTUNE -- Bright ideas about how to help the environment and in the process make a few bucks -- or perhaps even a few billion bucks -- abound. But which of them could actually work?
Might it be billionaire Tom Siebel's new venture, the mysteriously-named C3, which aims to use clever software to radically improve MOREScott Woolley - Apr 4, 2011 10:20 AM ET
The purchase will help Google with text to speech quality.
There aren't many details in Google's (GOOG) blog post on the matter but they picked up a small UK-based specch synthesis company called Phonetic Arts today:
But what about when the computer speaks to you—in other words, voice output? There are already places you can hear this in action today—for example, Google Translate "speaks" translated text in multiple languages, and you can listen to navigation instructions MORESeth Weintraub - Dec 3, 2010 3:56 PM ET
Better Place is working with GE to finance purchases of batteries for its switching stations and electric car system. But since most EVs come with the batteries built in, the financing won't be a panacea for the pricey new cars.
The electric vehicle industry's major hurdle these days is the exact same piece of hardware that's supposed to power it. Batteries for electric cars can cost up to $10,000 a piece. MOREShelley DuBois, writer-reporter - Nov 9, 2010 12:45 PM ET
How a founding editor of WIRED learned to live with technology like the Amish do
My favorite part of Kevin Kelly's new book "What Technology Wants" is the story he tells about how his first computer -- an Apple II -- changed his life.
You see, although Kelly is one of America's most influential tech writers -- he was the editor of the Whole Earth Review, one of the founders of the MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Nov 8, 2010 12:49 PM ET
The government 2.0 movement is about change, real change, and how to use the power of tech to empower the public. Here's how it will work, and who's already behind it.
By John Moore, contributor
There is a movement underway, called Government 2.0, a movement is crucial to our future as a society and one that's I'm a part of -- an inside man, if you will. Let me tell you about MOREOct 1, 2010 1:53 PM ET
|Albertsons to merge with Safeway|
|Chrysler Group orders donated Vipers destroyed|
|Everything must go: There's a flood of store closings|
|The real reasons to export U.S. gas|
|Bitcoin matters. Ignore the media circus.|