South Korea

Did an Apple 2.0 story touch a nerve at Samsung HQ?

April 21, 2013: 2:57 PM ET

A piece about Samsung's agent provocateurs seems to have stirred up a hornets nest

Screen Shot 2013-04-21 at 2.38.14 PMFORTUNE -- A funny thing happened on this site Sunday afternoon, Korea Standard Time.

On Saturday, following Samsung Taiwan's admission that it had paid anonymous posters to trash a competitor's products on Taiwanese social media sites, I posted a story about the growing suspicion among Apple (AAPL) investors that Samsung was engaged in a similar campaign against Apple -- and that it might be affecting the company's share price.

The post drew more that the usual number of comments. Twenty six hours later, we're up to 343 messages and counting. Some readers supported the thesis. Some ridiculed it. Some attacked Apple. Some attacked me.

That kind of thing comes with the territory, although not usually in such numbers or with such vehemence. But what happened at about 2 a.m. EST -- Sunday afternoon in Seoul, South Korea -- was new.

In the space of a few hours, more than a thousand votes were cast on the DISQUS feedback system, voting down any comment remotely anti-Samsung and voting up anything -- no matter how inane, in-artful or wrong -- that disparaged Apple, the thesis, or me.

For example:

betheball11: "Philip Elmer-DeWitt how much apple stock do you own?" (27 up votes)
Philip Elmer-DeWitt: "None. But thanks for asking." (22 down votes)

One of the posts that stirred up the most negative reaction overnight was a particularly thoughtful dispatch from South Korea itself, written by an ex-pat who calls himself Jake_in_Seoul.

Just to show that voices like his can't be silenced, I'm reposting it in full:

Thanks, PED, for writing on this important and complicated topic that people here in Korea speculate on privately. Many of the comments have been excellent, but here are a few nuances and personal perspectives that may be germane.

1. Samsung is a huge conglomerate, comprising somewhere around 80 individual companies involving everything from engineering, shipbuilding (2nd largest in the world), to hotel management, etc. with an even more complicated network of subsidiaries and joint ventures around the world. They own a major advertising agency and various large financial institutions (credit cards, insurance, securities). If they do choose to go into corporate warfare they have a wide range of expertise and global connections at hand to do so.

2. The Western press has been shamefully reluctant to pay close attention to even the normal details of Samsung's finances and functioning, compared to say, Apple, Google, and Microsoft, much less the extraordinary ones. Where is, for example, any in-depth discussion of the remarkable fact that Samsung Electronics has 3 "co-CEOs" or a good analysis of the longer-term implications of losing their largest customer? Korean analysts are likely too cowed by the possible threat of career suicide ever to write negatively of the company, reporters from Reuters, the WSJ, and FT, etc. only write puff pieces that raise doubt as to whether the material was drafted by Samsung PR. And worst of all, every press outlet on the planet keeps using (and treating as genuine) dodgy estimates of Samsung's mobile unit sales because the company refuses to release official numbers. Why should the supposed world leader keep its sales data secret?

3. I think it's fair to say that Samsung is not generally well liked by the Korean people, who are outraged, for example, at the high prices the company charges in local markets for their products ("we are all Samsung "patsies" Korean:호구, goes the frequent online lament). As brands go, I suspect LG is far more favored emotionally. And, while it's easy as outsiders to make Samsung into a mirror of Korea, I would urge caution. Do Wall Street institutions such as Goldman Sachs and CNBC really represent, for example, the essence of U.S? Sadly, in some manner, yes, but in the most important ways, I believe, no. So, too, Samsung. As an outsider who speaks Korean living here, I am continue to be amazed at the good people, extraordinary culture, and vibrant energy toward building a better future that I see here daily.
 It's a great place, generally, and using Samsung is a sad way to judge it.

4. Do I personally think that many at Samsung believe they are in in a global battle with Apple to gain respect for Korea and demonstrate to the "arrogant Americans" the superiority of Korean technology and business practice? Absolutely. It has the overtones at times of a holy war, especially after the jury verdict last August. And would this sense of righteous moral struggle lead the company to launch PR and financial attacks in order to enhance the company's prestige and honor? Very, very likely, in my opinion.

Thanks, Jake.

UPDATE: At the suggestion of several readers, I'd like to draw your attention to another worthy essay that was been hit with a lot of negative votes (165 and counting). It was submitted as a comment here by a Korean-American who posts under the tag alexkhan2000. As he explains, his handle is a portmanteau of two of his heroes: Alexander the Great and Genghis Khan.  Enjoy.


  • Samsung's Galaxy S4: What the Koreans are saying

    Usually it's Apple that gets savaged by Korean users. Not this time.

    FORTUNE -- "The initial reaction from South Korean users -- garnered Friday from 100s of comments to the news aggregator Naver -- ranges from tepid praise to complete scorn for the Galaxy S4, with negative comments currently predominating around 4:1."

    So wrote our Seoul-based reader "Jake_in_Seoul" in the commentary to Friday's post Samsung's Galaxy S4: What the press is saying.

    Jake has written MORE

    - Mar 16, 2013 10:37 AM ET
  • Video: Apple's iPhone 5 draws crowds in Samsung's home turf

    Record pre-sales and customers lining up in sub-zero temperatures

    FORTUNE -- In contrast to the ho-hum launch of the iPad mini in China, the iPhone 5 made a pretty good splash Friday in South Korea, home of Apple's (AAPL) chief smartphone rival, Samsung.

    According to the local Yonhap News Agency, the launch -- delayed from Apple's original schedule due to "procedural errors" registering the device with the government -- managed to draw crowds MORE

    - Dec 7, 2012 10:30 AM ET
  • Welcome to the 'Republic of Fakes'

    Forgeries and patent infringement are rampant in South Korea -- sometimes to a shocking degree.

    By Michael Fitzpatrick, contributor

    "Creativity is great, but plagiarism is faster." -- Ken Ndaru, author

    FORTUNE -- Some off the notorious copy-cating prevalent in the tech industry was highlighted on August 25 when a US court ruled S. Korean giant Samsung had ripped off Apple's designs. The most damning evidence: an internal memo from Samsung's head of MORE

    Sep 10, 2012 9:21 AM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • Video: South Koreans going crazy for the new iPad

    iPad fever spreads around the world

    FORTUNE -- Continuing its most aggressive rollout of an iOS device to date, Apple (AAPL) on Friday launched its new iPad in a dozen more countries, starting with South Korea.

    Judging from the video below, the event in Seoul followed the usual over-the-top script, from the line sitters who show up the night before to the staffers whooping and hollering the next morning.

    Over the course of MORE

    - Apr 20, 2012 11:26 AM ET
  • Where the CDMA iPhone goes next

    After the U.S (with Verizon) and South Korea, Apple is likely to target China, India and Japan

    The iPhone built around the CDMA protocol that Apple (AAPL) launched in February went first to Verizon (VZ).

    That made sense, since Verizon Wireless, with 94 million customers, represents the world largest market for CDMA mobile phones.

    But as J.P. Morgan's Mark Moskowitz points out in a note to clients issued Tuesday, Verizon's is not the MORE

    - Apr 13, 2011 9:48 AM ET
  • The world's fastest Internet access—who's got it?

    New research ranks the countries with the fastest Internet connections, and all 50 U.S. states too.

    The speed at which people around the world connect to the Internet is climbing at a 14% annual clip and now averages nearly 2 megabits per second, according Akamai's "State of the Internet" report that is due out tomorrow.

    There remain huge variations around that average speed. South Koreans hook into the Internet at 14 MORE

    - Jan 23, 2011 6:00 AM ET
  • Police raid Google's South Korean HQ over Streetview data

    Another country loses it over Streetview data.

    Korean Googlers today received an unexpected visit in the form of a raid by police this morning.  The cops were after that Steetview data that Google had admitted to erroneously collecting many months ago and any information they could find related to its spying on Korean citizens.

    "(The police) have been investigating Google (GOOG) Korea LLC on suspicion of unauthorized collection and storage of data on unspecified MORE

    - Aug 10, 2010 8:55 AM ET
  • The iPhone is headed to Seoul

    South Korea could be getting Apple's smartphone as early as next week

    According to wire service reports, government regulators finally cleared the way Wednesday for the launch of Apple's iPhone in South Korea.

    The Korean Daily News reported Wednesday that KT Corp. (KTC) -- the country's second-largest carrier -- plans to start taking Internet orders for the iPhone on Thursday and begin sales on Nov. 28.

    South Korea's largest carrier, SK Telecom (SKM), MORE

    - Nov 18, 2009 7:35 AM ET
    Posted in: , ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.