smart grid

Is it time to bury our power lines?

December 1, 2011: 5:00 AM ET

A series of severe storms this year has left millions without electricity. An affordable solution may exist.

By Brian Dumaine, senior-editor-at-large

A late-October blizzard damaged power lines in Glastonbury, Conn.

FORTUNE -- The freak snowstorm that hit the Northeast on Halloween weekend felled branches and trees at a dizzying rate -- New York City's Central Park alone lost 1,000 trees -- and downed hundreds of power lines. The blizzard left some 2 million without electricity -- many for more than a week. The even weirder thing is that this didn't really need to happen. As severe storms become more frequent and the losses from closed businesses and absentee workers add up, one is tempted to ask a very simple question: Why don't we bury our power lines?

Well, it turns out the answer isn't so simple. Numerous studies conducted by utilities over the years conclude that it is not economically feasible to bury lines. The most common estimate is that it costs 10 times more to bury them than to string them on poles. The North Carolina Utilities Commission said that burying wires statewide would cost $41 billion, take 25 years, and would more than double monthly electric bills. The news gets more discouraging. Some experts say that underground cables are more reliable than those above ground but only by about 50%, and that advantage is somewhat counteracted when you consider that it takes much longer to find, dig up, and repair a faulty wire. Why do underground cables fail at all? Floods and earthquakes can short lines. There's more: The roots of a tree toppled in a storm could destroy a buried wire.

6 ideas that could change tech for good

Is it that hopeless? Maybe not, argues Gerry Sheerin, an engineer and consultant in Ontario, who thinks the studies on cost and reliability are out of date and too high, perhaps by a factor of two. "Putting wires underground is absolutely a last resort with utilities, so they don't have much experience doing it and tend to overestimate the difficulties involved." That said, most new housing developments today bury their cables, helping the industry to gain experience. A nationwide program to bury wires could create economies of scale that would drive down costs. Also, new sensor technology could help spot breaks in underground lines, speeding repairs.

Who would pay for all of this? Public utilities commissions are unlikely to grant huge rate increases to utilities to bury lines. In this economy, not many homeowners would cough up cash for underground lines, even though doing so could boost curb appeal and thus house values.

That leaves the federal government. The DOE has programs for improving the nation's grid, yet no one in Washington is seriously talking about allocating funds to bury power cables. The issue at least should be studied more. Will the cost of burying lines be offset by the billions that could be saved from not having to repair overhead lines and avoiding economic disruptions? No one knows. Maybe we should find out. In the meantime, get your flashlights and bottled water ready.

--Reporter associate: Caitlin Keating

This article is from the December 12, 2011 issue of Fortune.

  • The smart grid requires smart consumers

    Next-gen energy distribution depends on getting users engaged and educated.

    By Will West, CEO and co-founder, Control4

    The Smart Grid—the next-generation energy distribution network now being rolled out—offers something for everyone: Greater transparency and lower costs for consumers. New opportunities for technology providers, appliance and consumer electronics makers, and power utilities. A smaller carbon footprint for the planet.

    But there's a catch: none of it will happen unless consumers actually embrace and use MORE

    Feb 10, 2010 10:00 AM ET
    Posted in: , ,
  • Cybercrime, the next generation

    The popular platforms of today are bound to be the targets of tomorrow

    By Kevin Prince, chief technology officer, Perimeter E-Security and Doug Howard, former chief strategy officer

    (The following is adapted from the forthcoming book, Security 2020, scheduled to be published later this year.)

    The social networking (think Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, MySpace) phenomenon is only going to grow. And anytime there is a system, program, or process used by MORE

    Feb 9, 2010 10:00 AM ET
  • A Twitter feed for your energy bill?

    The smart grid's greatest asset -- real time information -- remains largely unused By Bob Lento, president of information management, Convergys "You could save $5 if do your laundry at night." That's the way utility companies hope to entice millions of Americans to use smart meters, which will help people and energy companies reduce peak hour energy demand and the burden it has on their pocketbooks.

    To me it feels like déjà vu. MORE

    Dec 29, 2009 10:00 AM ET
  • GE brings good things to startups

    Conglomerate invests money - and its considerable resources - in young energy firms.

    By Marc Gunther, contributing editor

    When A123 Systems (AONE), a startup company that makes advanced lithium-ion batteries, had a successful initial public offering last month, one of the big winners was General Electric (GE).

    That's because A123 Systems is by far the biggest holding of a venture capital fund run by GE that invests in energy startups. Over six rounds MORE

    Oct 15, 2009 8:00 AM ET
  • IBM's Smarter Planet: the roadshow

    Live from New York, it's Sam Palmisano.

    The business strategy made possible by $50 billion in acquisitions, hundreds of millions on marketing, and various forms of ecological disaster, is taking the show on the road–to Manhattan's Lincoln Center.

    For the next day and a half, IBM's (IBM) Smarter Planet initiative will occupy New York City's Lincoln Center in the form of a conference on developing smarter cities. IBM CEO Sam Palmisano and MORE

    - Oct 1, 2009 7:03 AM ET
  • Smart solutions to big problems

    Can smarter networks save the planet?

    Unlike many technology confabs the upcoming Brainstorm Tech event is produced by journalists with the aim of creating a conference that is an informative, lively and multifaceted as a feature article in a magazine. Fortune writers and editors always get good story ideas from Brainstorm Tech. But sometimes the conference anels and discussions evolve from stories we've already run in the magazine or online.

    One such MORE

    - Jul 16, 2009 8:00 AM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.