sharing economy

Driver liability issues raise questions for car-sharing startups

February 6, 2014: 5:00 AM ET

Companies like Uber and Lyft face another gray area after the death of a young girl earlier this year.

140204180234-uber-620xa

FORTUNE -- When is an Uber driver an Uber driver, and what happens when there's an accident?

Million-dollar questions like these -- and more -- are being asked in the aftermath of Sofia Liu's death. On New Year's Eve, the 6-year-old was struck and killed by Syed Muzzafar in his gray Honda Pilot as she crossed an intersection in San Francisco's Tenderloin neighborhood. Weeks later, Liu's family filed a wrongful death suit against Muzzafar and Uber, alleging Uber was also responsible because Muzzafar was looking for passengers and had the Uber app open on his smartphone.

"Under the law, is the clock ever off? When are these guys deemed to be on?" wonders Ara Jabagchourian, a partner with the Los Angeles-based law firm, Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, LLP. (Jabagchourian is not involved with the case.)

MORE: Twitter plays defense on its first earnings call

Uber argues its drivers can work whenever they please, a draw for some former cab drivers used to working regular shifts. But drivers -- or at least Uber X drivers -- should note the company's insurance policy works similarly. Black car drivers, for instance, are required to have commercial insurance that covers them at all times, whether that insurance is covered by the driver or their employers. Likewise, Uber X drivers are contractors, not company employees, and what their coverage looks like can wildly vary: Some may be covered via commercial insurance because of another employer or because the driver opted for it, but by no means is it mandatory for an Uber X driver to have it.

Instead, Uber has a million-dollar insurance policy covering potential damages like those the Lui family is seeking, but that policy kicks in from the moment a passenger hails an Uber X driver with the Uber app until the moment the passenger is dropped off. And if an accident does happen, the policy either kicks in to make up the difference between what a driver's personal insurance covers and damages sought, up to and including $1 million; or if the driver is for any reason uninsured or underinsured.

Uber's competitor, Lyft, offered somewhat similar insurance coverage until this Wednesday when Lyft expanded its scope. The startup introduced collision coverage of up to $50,000, provided Lyft drivers already have personal collision coverage of their own. According to Lyft spokesperson Erin Simpson, several Lyft drivers have previously run into problems with their personal insurance providers regarding accidents once the provider realized they drove for a ride-sharing service. So Lyft's collision coverage is intended as a guarantee for drivers when they're on the clock -- not a standalone plan. (In addition, Lyft's new policies now offer coverage up to $1 million for uninsured or underinsured motorists.) Lyft also announced participation in the Peer-to-Peer Rideshare Insurance Coalition, a group of transportation companies -- one that includes competitor Sidecar -- as well as regulators, insurance providers, and other stakeholders trying to address insurance issues within the space.

MORE: How Josh James landed $125 million in funding from his hospital bed

In Muzzafar's case, Uber argues it isn't liable because he was merely looking for passengers but hadn't found one yet. If a user had already hailed Muzzafar and Muzzafar was en route to pick them up, or an Uber passenger was already in the car, Uber's million-dollar policy would apply, but only then, if the driver's personal insurance isn't enough to cover all the damages.

The reality is less clear-cut. "The argument could be made they [drivers] are using the app while they're driving, and obviously use of cell phone is illegal in California," points out Jordanna Thigpen, a Los Angeles attorney with Westerman Law Corp. and former executive director of the San Francisco Taxi Commission. Currently, liability as it pertains to a company like Uber largely varies by city or state. And while there remains much to be sorted out, Thigpen argues for balanced legislation -- neither lacking, nor stifling innovation -- for the ride-sharing space. Says Thigpen: "There's a reason transportation has been regulated for over 100 years. If you leave mass people to their own devices, well, it's not a good idea."

  • Behind Airbnb's legal fights, grassroots activism

    In courtroom battles against the room-rental service, elected officials find themselves facing a surprising opponent: the people.

    FORTUNE -- The week before Thanksgiving, roughly 200 Airbnb hosts and community organizers sat shoulder-to-shoulder at The Alley, a Midtown Manhattan co-working space popular with techies. The event was convened by Peers, an organization developed to support the growth of the sharing economy.

    An Airbnb host named Mishelle Farer got up to speak. Farer explained MORE

    - Dec 9, 2013 4:05 PM ET
  • Airbnb goes mobile with new apps

    New products enable the startup's 350,000 hosts to do without the desktop.

    FORTUNE -- Airbnb wants its hosts to get out of the house.

    At a press event Tuesday at the company's San Francisco headquarters, co-founders Brian Chesky, Joe Gebbia, and Nate Blechzarczyk introduced redesigned Apple (AAPL) iOS and Google (GOOG) Android apps with an emphasis on improving the mobile experience for the company's 350,000 hosts.

    "Hosts said they don't have all the tools that MORE

    - Nov 12, 2013 3:11 PM ET
  • FON's new Wi-Fi router is a community hotspot

    Buyers can use other FON routers anywhere, free of charge.

    By Michal Lev-Ram, writer

    FORTUNE -- The "sharing economy" seems to be working for cars and vacation rentals, so why not Wi-Fi?

    FON, a Madrid-based company, is trying to cash in on the growing collaborative consumption trend by offering a new, $59 router that turns home Wi-Fi networks into community hotspots. Users open up their network to other FON members, and MORE

    - Oct 23, 2013 11:24 AM ET
  • Wheelz acquisition: Another sign car-sharing is heating up

    Why RelayRides is buying Wheelz.

    By Kurt Wagner, reporter

    FORTUNE -- Peer-to-peer car-sharing service RelayRides announced on Tuesday the acquisition of competitor Wheelz, a San Francisco-based startup also connecting users with nearby rental cars. The deal's financial terms were not disclosed, but Wheelz's financial backers have agreed to carry over their investments to RelayRides. Wheelz has raised $15.7 million in funding to date, and investors include Zipcar, Social+Capital Partnership, and Fontinalis MORE

    May 14, 2013 6:45 AM ET
  • Airbnb to launch identity-verification tool

    Startup hopes new verified ID badges will attract more users.

    FORTUNE -- Starting April 30, Airbnb will go to even greater lengths to insure you are who you say you are, online and in the real world. The apartment-sharing site will begin rolling out a verified identification program that matches digital identity -- via social networking sites -- with real-world proof -- a photo ID. Once members have been verified, Airbnb MORE

    - Apr 30, 2013 12:00 PM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.