FORTUNE -- Since Spotify's launch in Sweden three years ago, the music streaming service has become an industry darling by popularizing the "all-you-can-listen" business model. But it hasn't always been smooth sailing for the startup. Securing licensing deals with the big four U.S. record labels for a stateside launch took longer than expected and, just last month, some 200 smaller UK labels yanked their content.
Now that Spotify is attracting millions of new users the question is, what will its profitability look like?
Earlier this week, MP3.com founder Michael Robertson argued Spotify and services like it are destined to be in the red forever. Why? He claimed that one-sided economics where all of the deal-making power is wielded by the record labels doom their businesses. If a service like Spotify doesn't play ball with one of the increasingly more powerful labels, its ability to offer content suffers. If it does, they can get stuck with onerous terms such as a deal structure where the service coughs up money for whatever ends up generating the most cash: revenue per subscriber, per track played or simply a percentage of the company's overall sales.
So are companies like Spotify, Rdio, Mog, and Rhapsody really stuck in a no-win situation? Not necessarily. Gartner analyst Michael Maguire believes it's possible to level the relationship somewhat. "I think services can start striking better terms over time, but what they're going to have to show is the ability to grow their audiences and maintain them," he says.
Meanwhile, the services themselves argue it's too early to call it a losing battle. "The music industry is constantly evolving and it's not new to hear skepticism around new content distribution models," Rdio COO Carter Adamson told Fortune. "It would be naïve to assume mainstream adoption will happen overnight, but what we have seen is that labels are invested in this model because of our innovation, great user interface, API and cross platform capabilities."
Key to success will be upping brand visibility. All four of the companies mentioned recently inked partnerships with Facebook, which temporarily resulted in a brouhaha over what the social network calls "frictionless sharing." Users who choose to do so now have their listening habits broadcast on the social network. It was a controversial move that paid off for Spotify nabbing it 7 million new registered users. (Spotify did not respond to requests for a comment for this story.)
Any question about how big eventual profits might be hasn't dampened competition. Spotify recently announced it would be compatible with apps from third-parties much like Apple's (AAPL) App Store and Google's (GOOG) Android Market. MOG is betting on efforts like MOG Fusion, a program aimed at getting its service in consumer electronics and cars. Rhapsody announced a partnership with Metro PCS (PCS), where wireless users can get unlimited music alongside unlimited voice, text and web.
The larger and more popular a service becomes, the more leverage it will have. With 10 million global users, just 2.5 million of which pay, Spotify may have to kowtow to labels now, but what happens if it actually hits those reported internal projections of 50 million U.S. users within the first year of stateside operation?
Much in the same way Apple had to overcome criticism and prove itself when it first opened up physical retail shops, Maguire believes when a music service has substantial growth and retention numbers behind it -- and therefore clout -- labels will become more flexible at the bargaining table. Maguire says that should happen sooner rather than later, as many of the services' deals with labels will likely be up for renegotiation starting mid-2012 through 2013.
If a service like Spotify accomplishes that, the question won't be whether it can be profitable, but when.
Fortune's curated selection of newsworthy tech stories from the last 24 hours. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you every day.
* Sprint (S) is betting billions that the next Apple smartphone will boost its business. The number 3 mobile network in the U.S. reportedly committed to buy more than 30 million iPhones and doesn't expect to make money off the deal until 2014. (The Wall Street Journal)
* Speaking of, Apple (AAPL) finally reveals MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Oct 4, 2011 3:30 AM ET
One of the most innovative online music services to come along in years has finally hit the States. Here's why you should be excited. (Hint: no monthly listening cap for free U.S. users.)
FORTUNE -- Yes, America, Spotify is finally here.
After nearly two-and-a-half years of promises and speculation, the music streaming service opened up shop in the U.S earlier this morning and already promises to potentially transform the way U.S. listeners consume MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Jul 14, 2011 11:49 AM ET
That depends on how broadly or narrowly the market at issue gets defined
The news that the Justice Department and the FTC are eying Apple's (AAPL) new subscription rules for possible antitrust violations has got experts taking a closer look at the markets in which the company competes.
"Typically when a firm reaches 60% or 70% of a given market is when authorities get interested," says Brett Gordon, an assistant professor at MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 18, 2011 12:08 PM ET
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter in your inbox every morning.
"I don't think Verizon needs the Nokia and Microsoft relationship. Right now the three OS players we see for our network are Android, Apple, and RIM." -- Verizon CTO Tony Melone (Business Insider and CNET)
Facebook revealed that a dozen or so smartphones with heavy Facebook integration MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Feb 16, 2011 7:54 AM ET
This week a software developer recounted a personal phone call from Steve Jobs to help fix his rejected app. But Derek Sivers recalls the CEO in 2003 as slightly less personable over issues with the iTunes Music store.
By Derek Sivers, contributor
In May 2003, Apple (AAPL) invited me to their headquarters to discuss getting CD Baby's catalog into the iTunes Music Store.
iTunes had just launched two weeks before, with only some music MORENov 12, 2010 1:10 PM ET
By Scott Moritz
U.S. regulators on Monday charged Dallas Maverick owner and outspoken blogger Mark Cuban with using confidential information in 2004 to sell his stake in Mamma.com, a Montreal search engine now known as Copernic (CNIC). His sale of all 600,000 shares helped Cuban avoid a 10% dive in the stock, or about $750,000 in losses, the government contends.
The Securities and Exchange Commission filed a civil lawsuit against Cuban on Monday. No criminal charges were MOREsmoritz - Nov 17, 2008 3:25 PM ET
|GM raising Corvette prices|
|Boeing reports wing cracks on Dreamliners|
|Albertsons to merge with Safeway|
|Bitcoin matters. Ignore the media circus.|
|Boeing to end pension plans for non-union employees|