Why getting into tech isn't as easy as you think

November 26, 2013: 1:15 PM ET

Silicon Valley companies are still hiring en masse, but for industry outsiders, getting a job can seem downright impossible.


FORTUNE -- The technology industry aims to invent the future. But for too many aspiring Silicon Valley workers, it's their past that's holding them back.

Who can blame any job-seeker for trying to break into the tech industry? There were 58,000 available Bay Area tech jobs this October, according to job data firm, Wanted Analytics. That's a slower hiring rate compared with this same time last year, but Bay Area tech hiring still trumps growth in other areas. Coupled with an endless number of high-profile companies like Facebook (FB) or Twitter (TWTR) paraded as success stories with humble beginnings, it's no wonder the Valley is often perceived as the nouveau American Dream.

The problem, according to several job recruiters Fortune spoke with, involves industry outsiders lacking realistic expectations when applying for jobs. To wit, a twentysomething undergrad with a communications degree from a top-tier school might think they have an excellent shot at landing a Google (GOOG) product manager gig. (They don't, unless they can answer reported technical questions like, "Write an algorithm that detects meeting conflicts.")

MORE: Why Amazon is goosing Prime memberships

"I definitely think people tend to overshoot and be a little too ambitious," admits Matt Mickiewicz, co-founder of the San Francisco-based Nearly 600 companies, from Pinterest to OpenTable (OPEN), rely on Mickiewicz's online marketplace to recruit new employees. And of the 3,000 to 4,000 new registered users sees every month, roughly 20% are from outside tech, usually gunning for positions like data scientist or product manager, that they are ill-experienced for. Hiring managers never even lay eyes on those applications -- the majority are filtered out at the beginning. Says Mickiewicz: "They don't want to look at resumes that are irrelevant."

"Entrepreneurialism by itself has become very institutionalized," argues Neil Warlicht, President of Wahl & Case, a Japan-based boutique recruiting firm with a San Francisco office. To date, it has placed people at tech companies such as Amazon (AMZN), Hulu, and Uber. Unless a candidate has a Stanford or Berkeley education and a notable startup name on their resume, they'll likely hear something like, "So, it's great you worked for Disney (DIS) or over at GE (GE), but that's very irrelevant to what we do," explains Warlicht.

Enter Norma Garcia-Muro. Muro served four years as Lucasfilm's Director of International Marketing, at times working with filmmaker George Lucas himself. But when Lucas sold the company to Disney in late 2012 for $4 billion, Garcia-Muro was laid off. She spent a year working the San Francisco tech scene and interviewing with over 10 companies for marketing jobs she believed she was a solid fit for. So Garcia-Muro was surprised when employers felt differently. And instead, she became familiar with a pattern: making it to the final round of interviews but getting passed over. (Garcia-Muro was made a job offer in one instance, but the company enforced a hiring freeze soon after.)

MORE: Is brick-and-mortar retail in a death spiral?

Garcia-Muro, who now works at a media company, ran into a wall then because of a common misconception that marketing jobs in tech are similar to those outside the industry, when they aren't. Explains Warlicht: "The amount of money Coke spends on branding is not necessarily quantifiable in terms of how much goes back to people actually buying Coke ... But for startups with very limited budgets, we want to know exactly where money goes and who is looking at what -- a different skill set, basically."

And just because a candidate does have prior tech experience doesn't mean they're a shoo-in, either. A startup might not hire an IBM (IBM) product manager for an in-house position because they don't seem like a cultural fit or might not excel under the comparatively unstructured workflow of a smaller environment.

That's not to say it's impossible for non-tech folks to make the transition. But to compete with MIT grads sporting computer science degrees means candidates must immerse themselves in the tech ecosystem. That includes staying on top of startup news and attending tech meet-ups. It could also mean creating a project for their desired employer -- wire frames for a proposed new product, analysis of a potential new business opportunity -- and sending it to the CEO or founder.

Says Mickiewicz: "Showing that kind of initiative is highly valued, and you're much more likely to get a callback."

  • OpenTable's rise and fall is a cautionary tale

    OpenTable is a reminder for investors eager for a piece of a hot tech IPO: It doesn't take a stock bubble on the scale of the 90s dot-com mania for investors to lose money on a supposedly hot Internet stock.

    By Kevin Kelleher, contributor

    FORTUNE -- Nothing lasts forever, but the speculative momentum that can drive up tech stocks is especially fleeting. Just ask OpenTable (OPEN).

    The company that made online restaurant reservations MORE

    Jan 3, 2012 8:50 AM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • How 'local' can tech get?

    FORTUNE -- Last week, during Fortune's Brainstorm Tech conference in Aspen, Colo., several of tech's brightest assembled to discuss ventures focusing on local services. Among them: Jeff Jordan of Andreessen Horowitz, Tim O'Shaughnessy, Co-founder and CEO of LivingSocial, Shopkick Co-founder and CEO Cyriac Roeding, and David Krantz, President and CEO, AT&T Interactive.

    Here is the unedited transcript of the panel:

    HOST:  Time now to talk about local.  "Reaching Local" is the topic of the next panel.  We've MORE

    - Jul 27, 2011 4:45 PM ET
  • Study offers grim news on deal sites like Groupon

    People may love online deals. But a Rice University study finds that bargain-hunters rarely turn into regulars.

    FORTUNE -- The growing backlash against daily-deals services got some fresh support this week from an academic study finding that fewer than half of the companies that use such services once are unlikely to do so a second time.

    The study, by Utpal Dholakia, professor of management at Rice University, also found that nearly 80% MORE

    - Jun 16, 2011 4:50 PM ET
  • OpenTable, broken stock? A lesson in the dangers of tech IPOs

    By Kevin Kelleher, contributor

    The company has done nearly everything right, but it's dangerously overvalued, even for a tech company. Should Facebook, LinkedIn, and Groupon take heed?

    FORTUNE -- Next Friday will mark OpenTable's second anniversary in the public markets. For most of its publicly traded two years, OpenTable (OPEN) has been an bright star in an IPO market struggling its way back to relevance. And for the most part, OpenTable has MORE

    May 13, 2011 3:35 PM ET
    Posted in:
  • Not Pandora's Box: Why the music company's IPO isn't the sign of a bubble

    Pandora's IPO might look like dot-com Bubble 2.0. But the company actually has a sound case for going public.

    By Kevin Kelleher, contributor

    In 1995, Netscape went public. Underwriters believed the stock was worth $14 a share but demand was so strong they doubled the offering price overnight. It rocketed to $75 a share on its first day. But Netscape was a browser maker, with no clear plan to make money. In time, it was bought MORE

    - Mar 1, 2011 5:00 AM ET
  • Behind OpenTable's success

    The online reservation service doesn't deserve its $1.5 billion valuation, at least not yet. But neither does it deserve to be written off as an over-hyped fad.

    By Kevin Kelleher, contributor

    Tuesday marked another ho-hum milestone for OpenTable: The stock closed at yet another record high.

    In the 20 months since its IPO, OpenTable (OPEN) has more than tripled its $20 offering price to Tuesday's close of $66.33. The 12-year-old company has amassed MORE

    Sep 23, 2010 12:05 PM ET
  • The Summer of (IPO) Love

    Will 2009 go down as the year the tech IPO returned?

    If you have been an investor in technology IPOs in recent months you've done well.

    Starting in April, and really gathering momentum this summer, there has been a slew of tech companies that leapt through the public market window including Changyou (CYOU), Rosetta Stone (RST), OpenTable (OPEN), and most recently Emdeon (EM).

    According to IPO research firm Renaissance Capital, the average overall MORE

    - Aug 25, 2009 6:00 AM ET
  • OpenTable - The hottest spot in town

    OpenTable, the online reservation service, is one of the few venture-backed companies to go public this year. Its secret ingredient? Technology that restaurateurs actually like.

    When online reservation service OpenTable (OPEN) went public in May, tech pundits gushed like foodies at a five-star restaurant. Some entrepreneurs and financiers hailed the $60 million initial public offering as a sign that tech startups -- and their valuations -- were poised to rebound from MORE

    - Aug 14, 2009 11:08 AM ET
    Posted in: , ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.