Import ban stands on Samsung devices that infringed Apple patents

October 8, 2013: 11:23 AM ET

When the ITC's iPhone 4 import ban got a Presidential veto, Samsung expected the same.

Banned: Galaxy S 4G

Banned: Galaxy S 4G

FORTUNE -- "The world is watching how Samsung is treated by the United States in this 'smartphone war.' The administration has a significant interest in avoiding the perception of favoritism and protectionism toward U.S. companies."

That's what Samsung wrote the Obama administration's trade representative after the International Trade Commission ruled in August that two Apple (AAPL) patents had been infringed by a raft of older Samsung devices, including the Galaxy S 4G, Fascinate, Captivate, Galaxy Tab and Galaxy Tab 10.1.

The administration had just issued a presidential veto of a controversial ITC ban on the iPhone 4, and Samsung expected no less.

The issues in the two cases, however, were very different.

The Samsung patents covered industry standards that the company had pledged to license under fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms. The Apple patents were not industry standards, and the company had not offered -- nor was it required -- to license them.

Nonetheless, Samsung was demanding the same treatment Apple got. The world, it warned, would judge the Obama administration harshly if it showed favoritism toward a U.S. company.

The Obama administration ignored Samsung's warning.

"After carefully weighing policy considerations, including the impact on consumers and competition, advice from agencies, and information from interested parties," wrote Trade Representative Michael Froman in a statement issued Tuesday, "I have decided to allow the Commission's determination in Certain Electronic Digital Media Devices and Components Thereof, Investigation No. 337-TA-796, to become final."

The devices covered by the ban are pretty long in the tooth and not big sellers for Samsung.

  • Apple's iPhone 4 gets a last-minute reprieve

    The Obama Administration vetoes an import ban that never made much sense.

    FORTUNE -- It was hailed by the Wall Street Journal as a "huge legal victory" for Samsung and blasted by pretty much anyone with a stake in the equitable application of U.S. patent law, from Microsoft (MSFT) to a bipartisan group of U.S. senators.

    But at the last minute -- on the final day of a 60-day review period -- the Obama Administration MORE

    - Aug 3, 2013 4:59 PM ET
  • President Obama has 48 hours to save Apple's iPhone 4

    The 60-day review period on the ITC's bizarre import ban runs out on Friday.

    FORTUNE -- Unless the White House intervenes, five older Apple (AAPL) devices -- including a version of the iPhone 4 that was one of the company's biggest money makers last quarter -- will be seized at the U.S. border starting Monday.

    The import ban stems from a June 4 ruling by the U.S. International Trade Commission that has MORE

    - Aug 1, 2013 9:29 AM ET
  • Barack Obama and Tim Cook's weekend chat

    I'll bet $82.6 billion the call had something to do with Apple's overseas cash holdings

    FORTUNE -- One of the business leaders President Obama called last weekend before he began his Southeast Asia visit was Apple (AAPL) CEO Tim Cook.

    The President met with a dozen CEOs last week to talk about the so-called fiscal cliff, and he reached out to four more over the weekend, including Cook.

    The White House did not MORE

    - Nov 20, 2012 7:40 AM ET
  • The answer to Obama's jobs problem

    The CEO of solar developer Recurrent Energy argues there are three things the president can do to unlock a new wave of job growth.

    By Arno Harris

    FORTUNE -- The White House announced that President Obama will address the nation on jobs after Labor Day. I have a suggestion for where the President could find part of the answer: by setting loose the 30-gigawatt (GW) buildup of U.S. solar projects bogged down MORE

    Aug 24, 2011 7:52 AM ET
  • Barack Obama's MacBook Pro

    The President may carry a BlackBerry on his belt, but he does his demos on a Mac

    Here's a nifty piece of product placement for Apple (AAPL): Barack Obama doing a demonstration of healthcare.gov on a MacBook Pro with the Presidential Seal where the glowing Apple logo used to be.

    The video, released Wednesday at WebMD, is pasted below the fold.

    There were reports when Obama first took office that his campaign staff, MORE

    - Jul 29, 2010 4:54 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.