mobile payments

Are Kenya's mobile banking services unfair?

February 14, 2014: 5:00 AM ET

Safaricom's latest venture M-Shwari hits a speed bump, threatening Kenya's leadership in the global race for mobile money and banking adoption.

By Erik Heinrich


FORTUNE -- Bob Collymore, CEO of Kenya's biggest wireless provider Safaricom, likes to say his company's mission is to transform lives.

In 2013 Safaricom did a lot of transforming, with Kenya -- the global leader in the advancement of mobile money -- reporting a record $22 billion in wireless financial transactions.

This latest figure, which accounts for more than 60% of the country's gross domestic product, compares to $17.4 billion in mobile transactions reported a year earlier, according to the Central Bank of Kenya.

The vast majority of this economic activity was conducted over Safaricom's M-Pesa platform, which has more than 15 million subscribers and continues to gain widespread acceptance as the country's primary system of payment for retail purchases and person-to-person money transfers.

MORE: Zimbabwe: Could it be Africa's first cashless economy?

Yet M-Pesa has begun to experience a backlash, with critics calling some fees and conditions associated with new services -- including a much-heralded savings and microfinance product known as M-Shwari -- heavy-handed and even unfair. That's a development that could stall Safaricom's ambitious plan of becoming Kenya's top retail bank in addition to being the country's leading wireless provider.

"The Kenyan authorities have long recognized the potentially detrimental consequences of Safaricom's quasi-monopoly status," says Michael Fuchs, a Chevy Chase, Md.-based finance and development specialist who spent years in Africa working for the World Bank, "but have been reluctant to disturb, or possibly derail, the m-money revolution."

Largely on the strength of M-Pesa's success, Safaricom reported six-month net income of $130 million in its latest quarter. That's the best half-year result in Kenya's corporate history and makes Safaricom, which controls about 80% of Kenya's wireless market, the most profitable corporation in East Africa.

MORE: Bringing financial inclusion to the Horn of Africa

There are a couple of reasons why Safaricom, 40% controlled by the U.K.'s Vodafone Group, has been able to turn M-Pesa into both a financial bridge to Kenya's unbanked masses and a huge moneymaker. It has invested $14 million per year to nearly triple the size of its agent network to 113,130 since 2010. That strategy has been critical to M-Pesa's success because agents -- typically retail merchants and gas stations -- provide much-needed liquidity in a country where most people do not own a bank account and cannot use ATM machines.

Also, since launching in 2007 as a mobile channel for money transfers, M-Pesa has year after year added new services aimed at attracting subscribers and lifting Kenya's unbanked majority out of poverty.

But the introduction of M-Shwari, a core banking service which debuted a little over a year ago in partnership with Commercial Bank of Africa, has been controversial.

On one hand, it has attracted more than 2 million subscribers by giving Kenya's unbanked access to interest-bearing savings account and credit for small purchases and emergencies.

MORE: Haiti's mobile redemption

"M-Shwari has seen huge uptake and proved the point that there is huge demand for affordable credit among the working poor," says Kathleen McGowan, senior policy advisor with the Washington-based U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID). "Mobile money providers around the world are increasingly moving toward partnerships with banks in order to be able to provide regulated financial services beyond simple money transfer services."

On the other hand, M-Shwari -- a key component of Safaricom's master plan of competing with brick-and-mortar commercial banks -- has drawn criticism for making too much money from Kenya's poorest.

Loans of up to $300 have a term of 30 days and carry a 7.5% rate of interest, which on an annualized basis works out to nearly 100%. "This is extremely high, and while such borrowing can provide relief to liquidity-constrained households, the transformative impact will be quite modest," says Fuchs, who helped oversee major financial reforms in Kenya for the World Bank.

Additionally, a higher rate of interest is applied if a customer pays off his loan early or late, and while a loan is outstanding, the balance in a customer's M-Shwari savings account is frozen up to the amount due. This creates a scenario where low-income Kenyans could in effect be borrowing from themselves.

MORE: Does Western Union need to watch out for bitcoin?

So far, Safaricom has not signaled any intention to change course with M-Shwari, which could cost Kenya -- a nation in which two-thirds of the adult population uses mobile money, higher than any other country -- and East Africa its global lead in the delivery of financial services on cellular phones.

The U.S. research firm Gartner predicts that Asia-Pacific will overtake Africa as the world's No. 1 region as measured by the value of mobile-money transactions in 2016, reaching $165 billion to Africa's $160 billion.

"Sri Lanka, Cambodia, Bangladesh, and Papa New Guinea are leading the way," says Sandy Shen, research director in Gartner's Shanghai office. "They also have a large number of unbanked and underbanked users and a strong commitment by service provider."

Much will depend on whether Safaricom, which has satellite operations throughout East Africa, is able to become the first company anywhere in the world to successfully transition from being a wireless carrier with a mobile wallet to a wireless company with a full range of banking services. If that is to happen, M-Shwari will likely need to offer more favorable terms to Kenya's poor from the slums of Nairobi to the cattle fields of the Masai Mara.

  • Zimbabwe: Could it be Africa's first cashless economy?

    Zimbabwe's biggest wireless provider wants to bring mobile-based money services to the currency-challenged African country.

    By Erik Heinrich

    FORTUNE -- Zimbabwean telecom tycoon (and the country's only billionaire) Strive Masiyiwa has been called a "global business influential," a "face of New Africa," and the "Bill Gates of Africa." He continues to live up to the reputation with a new venture that's as bold as they come.

    The founder and chairman of Econet Wireless, Zimbabwe's MORE

    Jan 22, 2014 10:41 AM ET
  • Square's Dorsey returns 10% of his shares

    Exclusive: The founder and CEO makes an uncommon move to expand the company's pool of shares for compensation and acquisitions.

    FORTUNE -- Jack Dorsey, the founder and CEO of Square, has voluntarily given 10% of his shares in the company back to Square. The highly unusual move will expand significantly the pool of shares available for employee compensation and acquisitions while minimizing dilution for shareholders.

    Dorsey owns approximately 30% of Square and MORE

    - Dec 20, 2013 4:59 AM ET
  • Stripe's co-founder on visionaries vs. implementers

    You need both, he says.

    FORTUNE -- Patrick Collison, 25-year-old co-founder of global online payment company Stripe, grew up in Ireland. After briefly attending Massachusetts Institute of Technology, he started several companies, including Auctomatic, which he co-founded with his brother John Collison and was later acquired by Live Current Media for $5 million in March 2008.

    Patrick and John now reside in San Francisco, where they founded Stripe, a company that has MORE

    - Dec 17, 2013 11:38 AM ET
  • Don't cut up your credit card (yet)

    Coin, Square and other next-generation payment technologies have credit card companies excited -- and scrambling.

    FORTUNE -- This week, I have bounced between decked-out department stores, cozy cafes, and speeding taxis, swiping my credit cards all along the way, more than 20 times in total. Despite the iPhone in my pocket -- an Internet-connected device that can communicate, geolocate, and yes, pay for goods across the globe with one tap of MORE

    - Dec 10, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • Bringing financial inclusion to the Horn of Africa

    Zaad mobile wallet powers economic development and job creation in Somaliland.

    By Erik Heinrich

    FORTUNE -- Somaliland is an African region balancing on a knife's edge. Separated from Somalia, it's a stronghold for terrorist groups like Al-Shabaab and for high-seas pirates. With so much crime and political instability to contend with, Somaliland is perhaps the last place on earth you would expect to find the bleeding edge of the world's mobile money MORE

    Nov 1, 2013 12:51 PM ET
  • Haiti's mobile redemption

    Digital wallet is helping lift the island nation out of poverty while generating impressive profits for wireless carrier Digicel Group.

    By Erik Heinrich

    FORTUNE -- David Sharpe doesn't mind doing business in Haiti despite its reputation for being one of the world's most dangerous countries. Back in the early 1990s, the ex-U.S. Marine was in Somalia during Black Hawk Down and the former Yugoslavia during some of the bloodiest fighting in Bosnia.

    But MORE

    Aug 15, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • Death of cash? Maybe, but not quite yet in Japan

    Japan's e-wallet infrastructure is eight years old, but the technology has yet to really take off.

    By Michael Fitzpatrick

    FORTUNE -- How do you persuade a nation that is deeply in love with cash -- and even looks askance at credit cards -- to pay for goods and services with the swipe of a phone? Unfortunately for Japan's dawdling economy and the credit card firms who hope to thrust such mobile MORE

    Feb 20, 2013 8:44 AM ET
  • eBay is back!

    Supercharged by PayPal, the e-commerce company and its stock are red-hot. Watch out, Amazon!

    FORTUNE -- "I'd like to take you on a journey." A group of 2,500 eBay employees is assembled at the San Jose Civic, a concert venue a few miles from company headquarters. Their boss, CEO John Donahoe, is onstage, asking them to reflect on their work. "Close your eyes," he urges in a deep baritone. "What is MORE

    - Feb 7, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • The death of cash

    Tech giants - and startups like Square - want you to use your phone to pay for everything from gum to train rides. Here's how they plan to achieve cash-free nirvana.

    FORTUNE -- Café Grumpy is the kind of hipster hangout that wouldn't deign to trumpet itself. Tucked away on a quiet street in New York's Chelsea neighborhood, it's easy to miss. There's no sign out front, just a frowning face MORE

    - Jul 9, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.