Apple's newest vice president: Bozo or rising star?

Adobe's Kevin Lynch comes to Apple with deep roots and a lot of baggage

Lynch defending Flash. Click for video.

FORTUNE -- The news that Apple (AAPL) has hired Kevin Lynch, formerly Adobe's (ADBE) chief technology officer, to be its new vice president of technology, has sparked something of a civil war among Apple partisans.

Wired's Steve Levy called Lynch a "star."

Daring Fireball's John Gruber called him a "bad hire" and a "bozo."

"Now we find out," tweeted Dave Winer, not entirely in jest, "if Gruber secretly runs Apple."

So who is Kevin Lynch?

As AppleInsider's Daniel Eran Dilger points out, he's a seasoned software team leader who could help fill the vacuum created with the departure last fall of Scott Forstall.

Lynch also has deep roots at Apple. He worked at General Magic with Bill Atkinson and Andy Hertzfeld from the original Mac team, and at Macromedia with Apple marketing VP Phil Schiller and Randy Ubillos, creator of Apple's iMovie and Final Cut Pro. His personal webpage lists among the heroes that inspired him Douglas Engelbart, Alan Kay, Tim Berners-Lee and Steve Jobs.

But Lynch is perhaps best known for his public tussle with Jobs in 2010 over Apple's decision not to support Adobe Flash on the iPhone and iPad. Lynch made several videos during that period that he probably now regrets, but they give you a rare chance to see an Apple vice president close up.

Star or bozo? Judge for yourself:

From AllThingsD: Lynch defending Flash

From AllThingsD: Lynch defending Creative Suite 5

From YouTube: Lynch running over an iPhone with a steamroller

Posted in: Adobe, Apple, Flash, John Gruber, Kevin Lynch, Steve Jobs, Steve Levy

• What the iPhone wrought

  To celebrate the device's fifth birthday, John Gruber puts his finger on what it disrupted

  FORTUNE -- Clay Christensen, the father of disruption theory, was famously wrong about Apple's (AAPL) iPhone, telling an interviewer five years ago that the probability of its success was "limited."

  "Being a low-end guy," Larissa MacFarquhar wrote in the New Yorker last month, "Christiansen saw it as a fancy cell phone; it was only later that he realized MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Jul 3, 2012 6:48 AM ET
  Posted in: Apple, Clayton M. Christensen, iPhone, iPod, John Gruber, Mobile

• John Gruber jumps ship

  The equivalent, in podcasting news, of Conan O'Brien leaving NBC for TBS

  FORTUNE -- On Friday, Daring Fireball's John Gruber, one of the most influential Apple (AAPL) commentators on the Internet, began the latest episode of his Talk Show podcast by launching without preamble into a riff about Andy Pettitte's return to baseball.

  No surprise there. Gruber's podcast style is as idiosyncratic as his widely-read blog, and he'll use any excuse to MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - May 19, 2012 9:26 AM ET
  Posted in: 5by5, Apple, Dan Benjamin, Daring Fireball, Hacker News, John Gruber, Jonathan Mann, Mike Monteiro, Podcast, Song-a-Day, Talk Show, The Mule

• Apple: Evolution as revolution

  It's known as a disruptor, but the secret of Apple's success may be its incrementalism

  It's a bit of a shock to hear TidBITS tech editor Glenn Fleishman describe the iPhone as a "plain phone," but in many ways it is. As he explains it:

  Apple released the original EDGE-only iPhone when 3G phones were on the market
  It included a low-resolution camera when higher-resolution ones were available
  It avoided adding 4G LTE to the MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 4, 2012 11:20 AM ET
  Posted in: Apple, Glenn Fleishman, iPad, iPhone, John Gruber, Mobile, Steve Jobs, Tablets, TidBITS, Upgrades

• Apple public relations' new media pecking order

  How the news of the Mac's next operating system -- Mountain Lion -- got disseminated

  The top tech news story Thursday, apparently, has nothing to do with working conditions in China, or who owns the iPad brand, or even the fact that Motorola (MMI) may have to remove "slide to unlock" from its smartphones.

  No, the top 135 stories on Techmeme this afternoon are all about the next version of Apple's (AAPL) MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 16, 2012 3:50 PM ET
  Posted in: Apple, David Pogue, Jessica Vascellaro, John Gruber, Mac, Macworld, MG Siegler, Mountain Lion, New York Times, Niley Patel, OS X, PCs, Phil Schiller, TechCrunch, Tim Cook, Wall Street Journal

• Video: Gruber, Ihnatko and Snell on Apple after Steve Jobs

  One of the most fascinating panels on the Macworld stage during last week's Macworld | iWorld expo in San Francisco was a conversion about "The State of Apple" among Macworld editor Jason Snell, Daring Fireball's John Gruber and Chicago Sun Times columnist Andy Ihnatko.

  We've excerpted the part that interested us most: 5:40 about what happens to Apple (AAPL) without Steve Jobs at the helm.

  Our favorite bit: Ihnatko on why more companies don't emulate Apple.

  "When you try to MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Jan 30, 2012 3:13 PM ET
  Posted in: Andy Ihnatko, Apple, Chicago Sun Times, Daring Fireball, Jason Snell, John Gruber, Macintosh, Macworld, Macworld | iWorld, Steve Jobs

• ExtremeTech: Carrier IQ-gate is best reason to buy an iPhone

  A cellphone eavesdropping scandal casts a shadow on Apple's competitors

  Have you heard that every text message, every e-mail, every phone number, every keystroke made on a Google (GOOG) Android phone may be secretly recorded, logged and sent to your cellular provider by a tracking service called Carrier IQ?

  No? That's a surprise, because it's a scandal that's been brewing for several weeks -- ever since security researcher Trevor Eckhart discovered Carrier MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Nov 30, 2011 5:42 PM ET
  Posted in: Android, Apple, Carrier IQ, Daring Fireball, Extreme Tech, Google, HTC, John Gruber, Nokia, RIM, Samsung, Trevor Eckhart

• Steve Jobs: The best of the obits

  A few gems among the flood of tributes

  If you have time for only one story about the life and death of Steve Jobs, read Steve Levy's 5,000-word tribute in Wired.com.

  Levy, who covered Apple (AAPL) for MacWorld and Newsweek for most of his long career, has mined his notebooks of three decades of quotes and anecdotes and insights into what made Jobs tick. He writes:

  If Jobs were not so talented, if MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Oct 6, 2011 9:55 AM ET
  Posted in: Apple, Steve Jobs, John Markoff, Walt Mossberg, John Gruber, Brian Lam, Steve Levy

• Video: Meet the Apple press

  Gruber, Mossberg, Om and more. Walking the media line at the iPhone 4S event

  This 53-second YouTube video is what you might call media inside baseball.

  It was shot outside Apple's (AAPL) Town Hall auditorium while the invited press cooled their heels in advance of Tuesday's iPhone 4S event.

  That's the Wall Street Journal's Walt Mossberg with the white Van Dyke at the 28-second mark. Daring Fireball's John Gruber is the tall guy in dark MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Oct 4, 2011 10:28 PM ET
  Posted in: Apple, Cupertino, Daring Fireball, iPhone, iPhone 4S, John Gruber, Mobile, Wall Street Journal, Walt Mossberg

• Let's talk: 1 new iPhone, not 2?

  Apple watchers are reading a lot into the invitation to next week's special event

  If one assumes -- as many were on Tuesday -- that Apple (AAPL) puts as much thought into the iconography of its invitations as it does into the icons on its computer screens, there are several conclusions one could draw from the "Let's talk iPhone" e-mail sent to selected member of the media.

  The meaning of first three MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Sep 27, 2011 2:58 PM ET
  Posted in: Apple, Cupertino California, Daring Fireball, iPhone, John Gruber, Mobile, Siri, Speech recognition