FORTUNE -- The Attorney General letter has become a real phenomenon in recent years. A refresher: The move consists of a bunch of state attorneys general joining together to express umbrage over this or that hot-button issue. It's a political tool, in other words. State AGs usually have designs on higher office and, if they can show hard evidence that they've done something, it helps them when campaign season rolls around. They can say, "I joined the fight against the horrific practice of ... " whatever horrific practice they have officially come out against.
These letters rarely if ever take on anything that might be controversial, of course. It's always something that offends voters' sense of morality, or inspires their revulsion -- animal abuse, say, or those horrible alcohol-caffeine drinks aimed at the young. But that doesn't mean the AGs are always right. The latest letter, aimed at gutting a crucial provision of the 1996 Communications Decency Act, starts out this way: "Every day, children in the United States are sold for sex."
Well, that's true, and it's awful. But the solution proposed in the letter signed by 48 of 50 AGs is no solution at all, and in fact would be counterproductive, and meanwhile would stymie business on the Internet, if not render it impossible.
The AGs want basically to rescind the CDA's Section 230 so they can go after classified-ad sites, specifically Backpage.com, where ads for underage prostitutes sometimes appear. Section 230 is in no small measure responsible for the Internet as we know it today -- for good and ill. It protects Internet service providers (like ISPs, search engines, classified-ad services, and pretty much every site on the web) from liability for what its users might do. If it didn't exist, an ISP might be held liable for every bit of illegal content that passed through its servers, a newspaper's website might be held liable for some bit of slander posted by a commenter, and Google (GOOG) might be held responsible for returning search results linking to some site that offers pirated movies.
None of those businesses would exist in their current form without Section 230. That's why it was passed, almost unanimously, in the first place. Crucially, it allows Internet services to take action against users -- such as removing offensive content -- without legally transforming themselves into publishers of that material and thereby exposing them to liability. There is, therefore, a lot less offensive and illegal material online that there otherwise might be -- difficult as that might be to fathom. In one case, Zeran v. America Online, the court noted that the "amount of information communicated via interactive computer services is staggering," and holding service providers responsible for all of it would be impossible.
As Mike Masnick of Techdirt notes, before Craigslist was pressured into dropping ads for prostitutes altogether, it was reliably helpful in helping law enforcement agencies track down and bust human traffickers. When Craigslist dropped the ads, that didn't make the advertisers disappear -- it simply sent them elsewhere, including to Backpage. Going after Backpage would have the same effect, because the Internet is limitless. "This," Masnick writes, "is the crux of the issue: when you blame the service provider, rather than the actual law breakers, you don't stop the law breaking. You just make it harder to capture the actual law breakers."
That's not stopping the AGs, however, since they don't have to worry about such niggling considerations as the complete unworkability of what they're proposing. They have come out against child prostitution, and that's all that matters. And in doing so, they're quite consciously and knowingly confusing the public that they have sworn to serve.
None of which is to say that outfits like Backpage should get an easy pass from the rest of us. The fact remains that the company is in the prostitution-services business (though of course other things are advertised there, too), and the fact is that child prostitutes are advertised there with some regularity. This is a terrible thing. But while we can and perhaps should judge Backpage for the business it's in -- just as we judge usurious payday-loan outfits or sleazy-but-legal cash-for-gold operations (or, for that matter, websites that seem to encourage awful behavior by users) -- that doesn't mean we should rescind a law that allows the web to work.
Apple figured prominently in the Queen of the Net's 2013 presentation of industry trends.
FORTUNE -- If you don't have 23 minutes to watch the video of Mary Meeker's state-of-the-Internet report at AllThingsD 2013 -- or if you just want a chance to study more closely slides that she showed for an average of 14 seconds each -- here are the 10 that pertained to Apple (AAPL).
They covered everything from the MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - May 30, 2013 7:20 AM ET
The reaction to Yahoo's acquisition of Tumblr is way out of proportion to its importance. It could be a relatively small mistake or a marginal gain.
FORTUNE -- It is only recently that Tumblr started asking itself, "So, how should we make money from this thing?" As of today, that's a question that Yahoo and its still-new CEO, Marissa Mayer, will have to address. And yet it's not necessarily the most MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - May 20, 2013 2:34 PM ET
It's time for the Web 1.0 icon to put down its credit card and get back to work.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- Yahoo's $1.1 billion acquisition of Tumblr looks like an expensive and misguided attempt by chief executive Marissa Mayer to somehow make the Web 1.0 company "cool" again. Instead of innovating her way out of the mediocre corner of the Internet in which Yahoo currently resides, the former Google MOREMay 20, 2013 12:15 PM ET
A team of scientists at Los Alamos National Labs has admitted to using a so-called quantum internet two years.
FORTUNE -- Scientists at Los Alamos National Labs say they have been quietly operating a quantum internet for the past two years.
What is a quantum internet? It is a network that employs the laws of quantum mechanics to make perfectly secure online communication possible. Because the act of measuring a quantum object MOREMatt Vella - May 7, 2013 1:20 PM ET
Whomever President Obama nominates to replace outgoing FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski, there will be political fallout.
FORTUNE -- There are lots of different issues that the Federal Communications Commission can affect: from media ownership rules to broadband deployment to whether broadcasters must pay insanely large fines for "wardrobe malfunctions" and people swearing during live awards ceremonies. But as observers try to guess who might replace outgoing FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski, the issue MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - Mar 29, 2013 6:52 AM ET
We don't think much about where the Net comes from. But a close look at where it's going will tell us where the world is headed.
By Andrew Blum, contributor
FORTUNE -- The global economy has arranged itself around a short list of dominant cities, the endpoints for movement of all kinds: goods, people, money, and, increasingly, packets of digital information. These packets -- some trillion bytes a second -- travel MOREJul 16, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Time is still money in the world of high finance. But dollars are now measured in milliseconds.
By Andrew Blum, contributor
FORTUNE -- When, in 1924, the Western Union Telegraph Co. went looking for land for a new headquarters in lower Manhattan, it had strict requirements: The building had to be close not only to the New York Stock Exchange and the commodities exchanges but also to the company's existing operations MOREJul 16, 2012 5:00 AM ET
For developing nations that can't afford high-cost infrastructure, the solution may be simple: Cut the cord.
By Benjamin Schenkel, contributor
FORTUNE -- It's one thing to bring fiber-optic cable to the coast of a landmass; it's quite another to then build that network into the interior of that landmass. Without much infrastructure already in place, the cost of new broadband cables is extremely high. The result is a bitter irony: Those MOREJul 16, 2012 5:00 AM ET
The U.S. has a long way to go before it becomes the world's most connected nation.
By Andrew Blum, contributor
FORTUNE -- The Internet was born in the U.S., but we can hardly claim to have the greatest percentage of citizens online (in fact, we are 23rd, behind Slovakia). Why is that? We're accustomed to thinking the problem is the "last mile," meaning the connection between our phone or cable company's MOREJul 16, 2012 5:00 AM ET
|Light bulb ban set to take effect|
|Military retirees: You betrayed us, Congress|
|Ford set for most aggressive expansion in 50 years|
|I work 4 jobs and I'm still struggling|
|Twitter restores blocking function after outcry|