FORTUNE -- For Amazon, it's not a matter now of whether the company will collect sales tax in many states, but when.
On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a ruling from the New York Court of Appeals requiring Internet retailers including Amazon (AMZN) collect sales tax regardless of whether they have a physical presence in the state. Amazon and online retailer Overstock.com (OSTK) had previously argued that the 2008 law demanding companies without in-state physical facilities tax in-state customers was unconstitutional. After all, Amazon's ability to undercut the competition, including brick-and-mortar retailers, historically stemmed in part from tax-free sales.
It's the latest in a larger ongoing battle that Fortune earlier this year estimated costs state and local governments $11.4 billion a year "in desperately needed cash for streets, schools, police, and parks." Indeed, Amazon has fiercely fought off collecting individual state sales taxes for over 15 years, and consequently managed to offer pricing up to 10% lower than other retailers.
Brick and mortar stores should be pleased, since many have previously argued it was unfair that physical retailers be taxed and online retailers go tax-free. "It [the law] increases the competition not only for the pure online plays -- the Amazons, eBays (EBAY), and others -- but also helps the brick and mortar stores level the playing field," explains Gene Alvarez, Research Vice President for Gartner Inc.
Already, Amazon collects taxes in 16 states including California and Texas, where it has warehouses. (The company does not have a warehouse in New York State but opened a photo studio in Brooklyn this October.) Collecting sales tax in other states seems to be an inevitability, given the company's rapidly expanding footprint: The company has opened at least 50 new warehouses since 2010, part of a $13.9 billion investment in overall fulfillment expenses, Bloomberg reported this fall. Come January 2016, when proposed warehouses will be open in at least 20 states, Amazon will have to collect taxes from roughly half of the U.S. population.
The way Sucharita Mulpuru, a Forrester Research analyst, describes the situation, it's downright Sisyphean. "At this point, I think Amazon just wants to delay sales tax collection for as long as it can," she says, arguing the company is well aware its competitive strategy must eventually change -- it's simply a matter of when.
But Amazon hasn't given up on intervention on a national level just yet. In a statement issued Tuesday, Amazon called on Congress to devise a national solution instead of letting sales tax be dictated on a state-by-state basis, likely spurred by Bezos himself, who has previously called local tax collection "horrendously complicated."
If and when that happens, the playing field for retailers will be more level but may do little to diminish Amazon's massive dominance.
By one estimate, as many as six million retailers in the U.S. could soon owe sales taxes on goods and services sold in other states. Tax software providers are seeing dollar signs.
By Lynnley Browning
FORTUNE -- At Avalara, a sales tax software company near Seattle, it's time to import more orange toilet paper from France.
The private company, where orange-shirted employees call themselves "Avalarians" and the signature color extends to bathroom stalls, is MOREJun 19, 2013 11:04 AM ET
Some say collecting and remitting sales taxes would be too complicated and expensive for smaller businesses. But that doesn't seem to be the case.
FORTUNE -- Taxes on Internet sales have been talked about since the birth of e-commerce. In those early web days, one major objection was that taxes would be impossible to collect, given all the various local and state sales-tax regimes. Forcing merchants to adhere to the laws of MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - May 7, 2013 10:45 AM ET
|2 million Facebook, Gmail and Twitter passwords stolen in massive hack|
|Fast food worker: Protest didn't cost me pay|
|Job growth drives mortgage rate jump|
|Investors brace for big dip in stocks|
|GM to discontinue Chevrolet brand in Europe|