By Michael Fitzpatrick
FORTUNE -- Sony's best selling TV, the Bravia, translates as "ferocious, savage, wild, untamed" -- the very adjectives that are probably on the minds of Sony executives as they consider the latest bid from gaijin, or outsiders, to upset the highly ordered decorum of doing business in Japan.
The latest audacity aimed at Japan from beyond its shining seas? A U.S. hedge fund, one of Sony's (SNE) biggest shareholders, has proposed the firm should spin off up to 20% of its entertainment business and use the funds to revive and focus on its struggling electronics arm. In a May 14 letter to Sony President Kazuo Hirai, first published in the New York Times, Daniel Loeb, chief executive of hedge fund Third Point, suggested Sony take 15% to 20% of the entertainment unit, the one that makes Sony money, public. In the light of such counsel, which analysts have for years been calling on as sound if not essential, Sony shares are surging.
Oddly the reaction in Japan has been muted, with Sony merely issuing a terse statement to politely and gently rebut the advice, although apparently it may have come as a recent surprise that Mr Loeb held such a large control -- his fund owns 64 million Sony shares, which is about a 6.5% stake in Sony. "The entertainment businesses are important contributors to Sony's growth and are not for sale," wrote Hirai in Sony's statement.
It ends: "We look forward to continuing constructive dialogue with our shareholders as we pursue our strategy." A suggestion, given Japan's long history of not tolerating any shenanigans from shareholders, particularly foreigners with an eye out for the main chance, that would have better ended as "just as long as you are as quiet and undemanding as the average Japanese shareholder." Shareholder activism has never been much of a participating sport in Japan.
But there is hope. "Mr Loeb's proposal certainly came out of the blue, so I am not surprised that there is no immediate response," says Gerhard Fasol of Tokyo-based Eurotechnology. "And Mr Hirai did meet Mr Loeb which was not always the case in the past." However Mr. Fasol is unsure just how far Mr. Loeb may get. "He does not have that much power over Sony. After all they are not like Sharp ," he says. "They don't have the same problems as Sharp so they don't have a gun to their heads." The hope must be that like the the other Bravia that is plaguing Sony -- its eight years of loss-making TVs -- the foreign meddlers might just disappear.
Struggles with foreign shareholders have nearly always turned to favor Japanese companies, after all. Just six years ago when Steel Partners launched a tender offer for the 90% of a famous Japanese sauce maker, Bull-Dog, the food firm sought a white knight intervention and then a poison pill to save itself from an aggressive takeover bid from the Americans. Finally, Japanese courts voted in favor of the pill.
Analysts here say an increase in more moves like this from foreign firms is further proof that Japanese industries now face a new era of corporate mergers and acquisitions that will more closely resemble deals seen overseas. Until very recently takeover bids were rare in Japan where private equity and hedge funds have been traditionally viewed as corporate vultures. Nor have efforts by overseas investors to wring higher returns from companies found much success in Japan.
Mr Loeb's tactics are less hostile. But historic evidence suggests that Sony and Japan Inc. are unlikely to heed his call, which essentially echoes the lead of the country's new prime minister, Shinzo Abe. His economic policies seem to have done so much to put Japan back on the map recently. Thanks to massive spending by the Bank of Japan, the nation's economy is on the up, though deflation is still the norm and firms are refusing to budge on lack of plans for new investments, according to the latest figures.
"Successful or not is Mr Loeb's call for action, we all agree that Sony must change, but how?" asks Mr Fasol. He suggests like the rest of Japan's big eight electronics makers, it is time to focus on a few products -- many reproduce in droves the same as their competitors -- and pick whichever can succeed. "Many other companies in Japan should focus like this, they all do too much," he says.
Regarding Mr Loeb's proposal, Fasol believes it constitutes major surgery. "I think that everyone including Mr Hirai agrees that massive change is necessary at Sony, and all other Japanese electronics companies," he says. "However, massive surgery is only one part. In addition, many changes in attitude, execution, company culture, etc. are also necessary -- but the most important are visionary products which I am still waiting for at Sony!"
What they care most about, a survey of 365 sell-side analysts found, are hedge funds.
FORTUNE -- As someone who has been tracking the forecasts of Apple (AAPL) analysts for nearly five years, I was not entirely surprised to learn that when 365 sell-side analysts (not just covering Apple) were asked what factors affected their compensation, the accuracy and timeliness of their earnings forecasts came in dead last.
This revelation comes from a survey MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 30, 2013 12:46 PM ET
Funds that were buying one and shorting the other are reportedly unwinding their trades
FORTUNE -- This was news to me.
Starting in February, according to Thomas Kee, who runs an outfit called Stock Traders Daily and writes a column for MarketWatch, hedge fund traders were buying Google (GOOG) and shorting Apple (AAPL).
"The trade worked quite well until about one week ago," Kee writes in Thursday's column, which is when the media MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Mar 14, 2013 12:38 PM ET
Because 13 of the 50 largest U.S. hedge funds were dumping their Apple holdings
FORTUNE -- Citigroup's Tobias Levkovich buried the lead when he reported Wednesday that Google (GOOG) had replaced Apple (AAPL) as the hedge funds' favorite stock in Q4 2012.
If you zoom in on his spreadsheet above (apologies for the bad reproduction) you'll see that Google made it on to one more top 10 list of the 50 largest U.S. hedge funds MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Mar 10, 2013 8:45 AM ET
How an Internet-trained Apple analyst lost tens of millions of other peoples' money
FORTUNE -- In the late 1990s, an ad agency creative director I'll call Joe Smith to protect his privacy bought several hundred shares of Apple (AAPL) at $60 apiece. Last fall, at age 42, he found himself out of work and increasingly dependent on the value of those shares to make ends meet.
Following the lead of a 33-year-old MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Mar 4, 2013 1:07 PM ET
SEC filings show banks and hedge funds selling Apple shares by the millions
FORTUNE -- There was a lot of selling pressure on Apple (AAPL) last quarter, to put it mildly. The stock ended the year down 25% from its September high of $705.07 and has fallen another 12% since then.
Want know where that pressure came from?
The big financial institutions -- banks, insurance companies, hedge funds, pension funds etc. -- that MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 15, 2013 7:33 AM ET
A gathering of hedge fund managers in Manhattan sends the share price on a wild ride.
FORTUNE -- See on the chart at right where Apple's (AAPL) share price dropped to just over $540 shortly after 3 p.m. Wednesday?
That corresponds roughly to when the fund manager pictured above left, DoubleLine Capital's Jeffrey Gundlach, told a room packed with investment managers that he was shorting Apple. "I just wonder how many people will MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - May 17, 2012 8:03 AM ET
The insider trader who pled guilty Tuesday leaked details about the iPhone 4 and the iPad
The wiretap caught it all.
Walter Shimoon, then a director at Flextronics (FLEX), a Singapore-based company that supplies Apple (AAPL) with camera and battery components, was being paid up to $200 per hour to leak insider information to a shadowy group of hedge funds and so-called expert networks.
In an Oct. 1, 2009 phone call secretly taped MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Jul 6, 2011 5:57 AM ET
When the stock sets new record highs, the naysayers come out of the woodwork
As a rule of thumb, never take investment advice from a hedge fund manager who posts his predictions on Twitter.
On Thursday morning, BAM Investor's J.G. Savoldi used the microblogging service (and a follow-up press release) to warn investors that Apple (AAPL) was about to crash and could hit $45 a share -- perhaps as early as this MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Jun 19, 2010 6:52 AM ET
Two years after Apple first broke $200, the stock sets a new all-time record high
"If you can keep a good stock down," wrote Jason Schwarz last week, explaining why hedge funds love Apple (AAPL), "then you are able to load up for the ride back up. It's like a slingshot — the harder you pull, the more propulsion you generate."
As if to illustrate his point, Apple shot to a new MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 24, 2009 12:13 PM ET
|Boost for trade as global deal struck|
|Five key numbers behind the jobs recovery|
|Someone bought a $100,000 Tesla with Bitcoins|
|2 million Facebook, Gmail and Twitter passwords stolen in massive hack|
|Where should you put your money now?|