It looked to me like a cheap shot by a London tabloid editor, amplified by the echo chamber of lazy journalism. See Who says Apple's iPhone 5 is the 'most-hated smartphone'?
Well I finally tracked down Ed Kitchingman, the senior analyst at We Are Social who did the original research.
"I thought you hit the nail on the head in your piece about the Mail and 'most loved', 'most hated,'" he wrote via LinkedIn. He also attached a link to a report on his findings that he posted this week on We Are Social's website.
As I suspected, his conclusions bore no resemblance to the "most-hated" business reported as news by, among others, the Daily Mail, ABC News, The Examiner, IT Wire, Android Community, The Droid Guy, Daily Finance, Mobile & Apps, International Business Times and The Boy Genius Report. (Links omitted; you can do the Google News search yourself.)
What Kitchingman actually found was that the iPhone 5 dominated -- by far -- the launch day conversations on Twitter and other social media platforms (see chart above), but that its competitors did a much better job of steering the discussion.
Samsung, for example, used social media aggressively to invite fans to be part of its launch, offering sneak previews, teasing content and encouraging them to "meet the next Galaxy" at a Broadway-style event in New York City.
By contrast Apple (AAPL), according to Kitchingman, "was not proactive enough pushing positive messages about the iPhone 5 and any innovation it offered, resulting in a low level of conversation around its features."
"[Apple]'s lack of proactivity and staid marketing tactics," he concludes, "leave the social space open for other brands to take advantage."
For Kitchingman's report, see Mobile launches: a social snapshot.
Probably the same London tabloid that called Samsung's Galaxy S4 the "most-loved."
FORTUNE -- Here's what passes for tech news on ABC TV these days:
"Tough news for Apple. Research firm We Are Social names the iPhone 5 the most-hated smartphone on the market for receiving the most complaints on social media. Last year, by contrast, the Samsung Galaxy S4 was named the most-loved smartphone."
That item, which aired Friday on at least MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Jul 6, 2013 9:55 AM ET
A profile in the Daily Mail blames it on an assignment to design a toilet
Lots of new details about the man it calls "the most successful designer on the planet" in Rob Waugh's long biographical profile of Jonathan ("Jony") Ive in Sunday's Daily Mail, starting with the toilet design that drove him out of England:
"The manner of his departure for the U.S. is particularly galling to Clive Grinyer, who MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Mar 21, 2011 6:51 AM ET
Is Steve Jobs preparing to launch a smaller, cheaper version of the iPhone in time for Christmas?
That's the rumor -- based on a brief item in London's Daily Mail -- that had Apple watchers buzzing over the weekend. "Report: iPhone nano to ring in the holidays" read the headline on Crave, CNet's gadget blog. "iPhone Nano Rumor Brings Hope Alive," wrote iPhone Savior. "Holy rumor, Batman," shouted Crunch Gear, "iPhone MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Aug 4, 2008 9:12 AM ET
|Regulators pave way for Internet "fast lane" with net neutrality rules|
|What stumps Warren Buffett? Minimum wage|
|Facebook profit triples on mobile growth|
|Apple shares soar on increased buyback|
|Analysts offer no apologies for missing Apple's Q2 2014 earnings beat|