FORTUNE -- The issue of government leaks is once again raising the question of who is and who is not a journalist, and whether we should ask instead whether a particular act is an act of journalism, regardless of who performs it.
Crucial, complicated questions. But what about when somebody who claims not to be a journalist writes some obvious nonsense -- say, about a company -- and a whole lot of people, including people on Wall Street, decide to believe it? In such a case, the question of who is and is not a journalist seems beside the point. People read it, they believe it, and sometimes, they act on it.
Case in point: late Wednesday, tech gadfly and blogger Robert Scoble wrote on his Google Plus profile: "I just heard an interesting rumor. Supposedly Google (GOOG) is renting 6,000 square feet inside every Best Buy (BBY) next year. Why? My source says it's to sell Google Glass."
Despite the ludicrous notion that Google Glass displays could take up 6,000 square feet (which would amount to nearly a third of the smaller stores, and more than 10% of the biggest), the post was taken seriously. The Pioneer Press, a hometown paper of the Minnesota-based Best Buy, reported that the rumor boosted the retailer's shares by 4% on Thursday. The paper offered zero evidence that the stock spike was related to the rumor, but given that Scoble has a pretty big audience (nearly 350,000 Twitter followers, e.g.), it seems a safe bet that he was at least partly responsible for the uptick.
But Scoble, though he weighs in constantly on all manner of tech stories, also insists that he's not a journalist. That makes it possible for him to have it both ways. He can write something for his huge audience, without ever taking any responsibility for it. "Now, this is a rumor," he wrote on Google Plus. "If I was a journalist working for, say, Techcrunch, I'd call around and see if I can verify this rumor. But I would rather let this hang out here and see if someone like Kara Swisher knows anything."
On Twitter, Kara Swisher, who runs the Wall Street Journal's All Things D blog and who openly admits that she's a journalist, wrote to Scoble: "No idea! Aren't you the expert?"
It's quite possible, of course, that Best Buy and Google are in some kind of talks. Everybody is always in some kind of talks with everybody else. Maybe they're even in some kind of talks for a Google Glass store-within-a-store (that would comport with Best Buy's current strategy, which investors seem to love). But when a rumor like this is accompanied by a ridiculous assertion -- 6,000 square feet -- the whole thing should probably be taken with a couple of cases of salt. The fact that it wasn't -- by stock traders and by online commenters -- confirms two things: in the short term, Wall Street is always insane; and many online commenters will believe anything.
The Pioneer Press, for the record, contacted Best Buy, which said it had nothing to announce.
Turnarounds at Dell, HP, and Yahoo generate more headlines than fast results. And then there's Best Buy -- lower-profile but showing progress against all odds.
By Kevin Kelleher, contributor
FORTUNE -- When was the last time you went to a Best Buy? And more importantly, would you consider going back? I ask question knowing that some of you -- you know who you are -- are laughing, or smirking, or at least have written MOREJun 12, 2013 9:35 AM ET
Embattled computer manufacturers are making new machines they hope can keep pace with phones and tablets.
FORTUNE -- For PC makers, Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution holds true now more than ever: adapt to their rapidly-evolving environment or perish.
"The PC industry is like that scene out of Jurassic Park, where the little kid asks the professor, 'What happened to all the dinosaurs?' and he responds, 'We see them everyday: They're MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Jun 4, 2013 6:45 AM ET
This AdMob vet wants to bridge the divide between desktop and mobile advertising. If she succeeds, even Google could find itself at a disadvantage.
FORTUNE -- Kamakshi Sivaramakrishnan never planned to go into advertising, much less run a startup. But when the 37-year-old Stanford graduate, with a Ph.D. in Information Theory, met AdMob founder Omar Hamoui, she turned her back on Wall Street and joined AdMob as a research scientist in MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - May 21, 2013 7:58 AM ET
Some say collecting and remitting sales taxes would be too complicated and expensive for smaller businesses. But that doesn't seem to be the case.
FORTUNE -- Taxes on Internet sales have been talked about since the birth of e-commerce. In those early web days, one major objection was that taxes would be impossible to collect, given all the various local and state sales-tax regimes. Forcing merchants to adhere to the laws of MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - May 7, 2013 10:45 AM ET
The new e-retailer wants to do for tech inventors what crowd-funding site Kickstarter has done for thousands of aspiring entrepreneurs -- without the risk.
FORTUNE -- For the modern inventor, getting her creation in the hands of consumers can be just as trying as conjuring up the product in the first place. "So many people who build hardware love building products but spend all their time doing manufacturing and distribution," explains 29-year-old MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - May 2, 2013 10:55 AM ET
Wal-Mart, Best Buy, and MacMall have all lowered their prices on iPads and iPad minis.
FORTUNE -- It's only been 163 days since Apple (AAPL) introduced the iPad mini and updated its full-size iPad line -- roughly half the tablet's usual 311-day product cycle according to MacRumors' invaluable Buyer's Guide.
In fact the guide, which advises readers when it's safe to buy an Apple product, still has a "Buy Now! Product just updated" recommendation MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 4, 2013 6:10 AM ET
What Tim Cook didn't say in last week's earnings call
FORTUNE -- When it reports on Mac sales in its retail stores, Apple (AAPL) likes to make the point -- as Tim Cook did again last week -- that roughly half of the Macs sold in Apple Stores are sold to customers who never owned a Mac before.
In a report issued Monday entitled "What Tim Cook Didn't Say," Consumer Intelligence Research Partners, MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 30, 2012 2:58 PM ET
Jefferies' Peter Misek takes a deep dive into the problem of acquiring quality content
Amid all the chatter this week about Apple's (AAPL) putative plans to build a standalone TV set -- from Best Buy's leaked customer survey to the Globe and Mail's report that Canadian telcoms are already testing the thing in their labs -- the 23-page report produced by Peter Misek's team at Jefferies International stands out.
Rather than get MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Feb 7, 2012 11:29 AM ET
The high-tech wundercompany landed not only on our street corners and in our malls, but also on the top 10 of Fortune's Most Admired Companies.
Editor's note: This article appeared in the March 8, 2007 issue of Fortune magazine.
By Jerry Useem
FORTUNE -- "Sorry Steve, Here's Why Apple Stores Won't Work," BusinessWeek wrote with great certainty in 2001. "It's desperation time in Cupertino, Calif.," opined TheStreet.com. "I give [Apple] two years MOREAug 26, 2011 5:00 AM ET
|The medical marijuana ad that never aired, despite contrary media headlines|
|2 million students missing out on college aid|
|China to fight pollution with drones|
|GM raising Corvette prices|
|Boeing reports wing cracks on Dreamliners|