alternative energy

Why Plug Power mania is bad news

March 17, 2014: 1:57 PM ET

Plug Power has become a battleground between short-sellers and speculators who don't want the mania to end just yet.

By Kevin Kelleher (@kpkelleher)


FORTUNE -- It's been five years since the stock market began to recover from the financial crisis, and the bull market shows few signs of slowing. But it is showing signs of erratic behavior. And the latest example for stock-market strangeness is a doozy: Plug Power (PLUG).

Plug Power is involved with fuel cells, an alternative-energy technology that promises clean energy. The company is based in Latham, N.Y., focusing on the niche market of fuel-cell-powered forklifts. Like many fuel-cell makers, Plug Power has proven better at burning through cash than delivering investor profits.

That hasn't stopped some investors from speculating in Plug Power and other fuel-cell companies. Over the past six months, several companies -- all with a history of losses -- have surged: FuelCell Energy (FCEL) up 136%, ZBB Energy (ZBB) up 143%, Hydrogenics (HYGS) up 180%, Ballard Power (BLDP) up 274%.

None of those approach the rally in Plug Power, which has risen 982% in the past six months and 3,680% in the past year. And that's after a roller-coaster period that saw the share price go from $6 a share 10 days ago to nearly $12 a share a week ago and back down to $6 a share at the close of last week.

Plug Power has become a battleground between short-sellers (short interest is 19.4 million shares) and speculators who don't want the mania to end just yet. Although the stock is down sharply from its $12 high last week, it did manage to spike up Thursday after reporting 2013 revenue of $27 million and a loss of $63 million. Some investors were willing to buy a stock valued at 32 times its revenue last year. And that was after the company said it burned through $27 million in cash last year.

MORE: On eve of stress tests, Fed asks banks for more info

Why should Plug Power mania matter to the broader stock market? After all, speculators have long flocked to small, money-losing companies with a product that one day, just maybe, could produce a huge hit. Tech stocks with an environmental angle are especially popular, since many investors understand the shiny promise better than the complex science involved or the daunting obstacles ahead.

And Plug Power is in many ways an ideal target for specuation. Founded in 1997, the company has a volatile history. Its share price rose as high as $1,500 in early 2000 and traded as low as 13 cents a share last year. In 2004, the company entered a $5 million settlement of a shareholder lawsuit alleging insider trading. The company has never even reported an annual profit, earning instead the dubious honor of 16 straight years in the red.

The trading in Plug Power bears another hallmark of a classic speculative rally run amok. Over the past 10 days, average volume has risen to an average of 129 million shares a day, well above the float of 88 million shares. On two separate days last week, every share of Plug Power available in the market was traded an average of three times a day.

Plug Power also has the appeal of a promised turnaround to spur investors on. On a conference call with analysts Thursday, CEO Andy Marsh said the company would post EBITDA of $3 million and that revenue would rise to $70 million from $20 million. But a scathing research report from Citron Research (which precipitated the plunge in Plug Power's stock last week) chronicled the company's history of overpromising on guidance.

Plug Power's surge is worth noting for a couple of reasons. First, it's far from alone. It's not just other fuel-cell stocks either. There are warnings of mini-bubbles in Tesla (TSLA), in 3-D printer stocks, in biotech stocks, and of course in the Internet sector, where a little known company like Castlight can go public at 107 times revenue and then rise 149% on its first day. In fact, a bunch of seasoned money managers and observers are openly declaring U.S. stocks in general to be near or in a bubble.

MORE: The one price Amazon is willing to raise

The Plug Power mania is also worrisome because the degree of insanity is unusual: Some observers said they'd never seen a mania quite like it. Also worrisome is it's not just day traders investing in Plug Power but large-cap hedge funds and a few mutual funds as well. The company sold 10 million shares to a "single institutional investor" in January and another 4 million shares to such an investor in March.

All of this suggests not just a tolerance toward but also a growing appetite for deals that can't even be rationalized. Speculation can spread like a fire into other stocks and sectors once investors see that there is a growing tolerance for irrational investing on a large scale.

Stock-market bubbles don't emerge out of nowhere, they take years to build, starting with little pockets of speculation and scaling up to bigger stocks as everyone rushes to pile in before the music stops. They are like cancers that offer early warning signs before they spread.

The madness in Plug Power this month may offer all investors one such early warning. The company was a speculative boom and bust in 2000, and it's starting to look like one now. History is repeating itself. Whether it does so in a few isolated sectors or on a much larger scale is something worth watching.

  • Electric power without lines

    Hundreds of companies are investing in electricity transferred through magnetic fields. How will it work, and will it replace wires?

    By Brian Dumaine, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- Backed by the financier J.P. Morgan, Nikola Tesla, the inventor and rival to Thomas Edison, built in the early 1900s the Wardenclyffe Tower, a 187-foot-high structure on Long Island, which he said could transmit electricity wirelessly. The project failed, and Tesla ended up broke. MORE

    Nov 1, 2013 9:21 AM ET
  • 10 Questions: Fred Krupp, president, Environmental Defense Fund

    The co-author of Earth: The Sequel on alternative energy, leadership qualities, and the most important thing he learned in school.

    By Chanelle Bessette, reporter

    FORTUNE -- Fortune's annual Brainstorm Green conference brings together individuals who strive to build a sustainable future across various industries. In this weekly feature, we shine a spotlight on an attendee to offer their personal insight on business, environmentalism, and entrepreneurship.

    As president of the Environmental Defense Fund, Fred MORE

    - Oct 8, 2013 10:37 AM ET
  • On climate change, we are the ones we've been waiting for

    The president's major speech notwithstanding, innovations in technology and finance mean Americans can play a greater role in their energy future.

    By Andrew L. Shapiro

    FORTUNE -- In his highly anticipated speech on climate change Tuesday, President Obama promised to limit power plant emissions, accelerate clean energy deployment, and bolster resilience to extreme weather shocks. These efforts are critically important, yet they will take time to implement and are already facing political MORE

    Jun 26, 2013 11:13 AM ET
  • NRG previews new Solar Canopy

    At Fortune's Brainstorm Green conference, NRG Energy CEO David Crane unveiled a new product that provides shade and solar energy -- and it doesn't rely on rooftop panels or the electricity grid.

    By Brian O'Keefe, assistant managing editor

    FORTUNE -- If all goes according to plan for NRG Energy, solar power will soon be the hot new thing in shade.

    At Fortune's Brainstorm Green conference this week, the power generation and utility company previewed MORE

    May 1, 2013 9:00 AM ET
  • In Abu Dhabi's energy oasis, setbacks and progress

    Masdar, the government's high-concept, energy-efficient desert city, is becoming more than an architect's dream.

    By Brian Dumaine, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- The last time we visited Masdar -- the green city being built in the desert sands of Abu Dhabi -- the project wasn't much more than an architect's scheme. Fast-forward and what you'll find is an operating university, the Masdar Institute, and nearby the energy-saving Middle East headquarters tower of Siemens, plus MORE

    Apr 29, 2013 6:47 AM ET
  • The fuel that could be the end of Ethanol

    Ethanol could be on its way out this decade thanks to a discovery that makes butanol more cost-effective.

    By Jennifer Abbasi

    FORTUNE -- In 2007 we reported on biobutanol, a biofuel with the potential to solve many of the problems associated with ethanol. Since then, industry players like BP have been seeking ways to make a cost-efficient transition to the "advanced biofuel," and now a scientific breakthrough might finally make that MORE

    Apr 12, 2013 7:25 AM ET
  • Moving beyond coal. Maybe

    What are the keys to leveraging alternative sources of energy and moving beyond coal?

    By David Whitford, editor-at-large

    Bill Weihl, Google's (GOOG) energy czar, suggests two new ideas: Encourage new technology through investments in R&D; and "generate market pull" with consumer incentives plus government procurement mandates. Can we get to low emissions without nuclear? "Probably," says Weihl, "but I hate to take it off the table."

    Mike Morris, CEO of American Electric (AEP), one MORE

    Apr 5, 2011 3:47 PM ET
  • The premature clean-tech IPO boom

    Early-stage green technology companies are taking a page from the biotech playbook: IPO with little or no revenues. So far, it's not working.

    A number of tiny, ambitious companies in a promising industry with a very small market are lining up to tap the public markets. It may sound like the biotech IPO boom of the 1990s, but this time it's firms in the clean tech industry filing S-1s faster than MORE

    - Aug 17, 2010 3:00 AM ET
  • Bloom box debut: More IPO than CO2

    The long-awaited unveiling may have another goal in mind: to fuel investors' appetite for a public offering.

    By Paul Keegan, contributor

    It was an awesome spectacle as product launches go: Speeches by Arnold Schwarzenegger and Colin Powell, a panel of top executives from Google, eBay, Wal-Mart, FedEx, Coca-Cola, and Cox Enterprises, video messages from Diane Feinstein and Michael Bloomberg, a heart-tugging slide show about saving the planet, and finally, after eight years MORE

    Feb 25, 2010 12:10 PM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.