Mac U.S. shipments grew 3.8% last quarter. Or was it 5.1%?

Why can't Gartner and IDC just get along?

Click to enlarge.

You used to be able to explain the discrepancies between Gartner's and IDC's quarterly market share reports by the difference in their methodologies.

Gartner counted sales to end users. IDC counted sales into "channel" -- i.e. devices sold to stores and other distribution points, but not necessarily to customers.

But when trying to understand the discrepancy between Apple's (AAPL) U.S. market share in the reports the two firms filed Wednesday -- 10.6% (up 3.8%)  according to Gartner, a round 10% (up 5.1%) according to IDC -- we noticed this footnote to IDC's spreadsheet:

Shipments include shipments to distribution channels or end users. (emphasis ours)

That doesn't help. If IDC is counting both channel and end users (or is either?), how does it come with a Mac market share that is smaller than Gartner's?

The discrepancy is even worse for the Acer Group. Its U.S. market share grew -3.8% according to IDC and -25.9% according to Gartner.

For the record, HP was the big winner domestically according to both firms' spreadsheets, with a share up 6.6% to capture 29% (Gartner) or 28% (IDC) of the U.S. PC market.

Worldwide, the PC market actually grew a couple percent last quarter. It had been expected to shrink 1.2% according to Gartner and 0.9% according to IDC.

Below: The firms' spreadsheets for worldwide PC sales for Q1 2012.

More

Posted in: Acer, Apple, Gartner, Hewlett-Packard, IDC, Mac, Market Share, PCs

• Merrill Lynch calls 2012 'the year of the tablet shakeout'

  Bank of America's brokerage division picks winners and losers for the year ahead

  The tablet market is "still in its infancy," writes Merrill Lynch's Scott Craig in a note to clients Wednesday, with "years of solid growth ahead."

  But that growth is not evenly distributed, and in his report Craig and his colleagues single out seven winners and seven losers.

  The winners: (I quote)

  Amazon (AMZN): We expect strong sales of the Kindle Fire (4-5mn MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 14, 2011 10:05 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Advanced Micro Devices, Amazon, Amazon Kindle, Apple, iPad, Kindle Fire, Lexmark, Merrill Lynch, RIM, Tablets, Yahoo

• Apple portable computers set to dominate the rest of 2011

  Especially if you throw in iPad sales, as yet another Wall Street analyst has done

  If you look closely at the chart at right, taken from a note to clients issued Monday by Deutsche Bank's Chris Whitmore, you'll see that it has two entries for the second quarter of 2011.

  Both show notebook computer sales as reported by the six largest vendors. The difference -- which Whitmore has highlighted with an orange MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Aug 8, 2011 7:09 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Apple, Asus, Dell, Deutsche Bank, Hewlett-Packard, HP, iOS, iPad, Market Share, Microsoft, notebooks, PCs, Samsung, Tablets, Ultrabooks, Windows

• PCs: Apple jumps to No. 3 in the U.S., even without the iPad

  Meanwhile, sales growth slowed worldwide as buyers shifted to smartphones and tablets

  The iPad was the elephant in the room as Gartner and IDC reported that worldwide PC sales in the second quarter of 2011 were even worse than their modest expectations.

  Shipments grew only 2.6% according to IDC and only 2.3% according to Gartner, well below the 6.7% Gartner had predicted and a fraction of the 12% IDC reported in Q1.

  Apple, MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Jul 14, 2011 7:14 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Apple, Asus, Dell, Gartner, Hewlett-Packard, International Data Corporation, iPad, Personal computer

• Consumer Reports [hearts] Apple's MacBooks

  Apple's notebooks sweep every category in the latest report, despite middling reliability scores

  Consumer Reports doesn't always love Apple's (AAPL) products. It still doesn't recommend the iPhone 4 because of problems its testing lab had with the external antenna. But in its survey of the current crop of notebook computers released Tuesday, the magazine gave the MacBook line its highest ratings in every category in which Apple competes, from the 11-inch MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - May 25, 2011 7:03 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Antennagate, Apple, Asus, Consumer Reports, Dell, iPhone 4, Laptop, MacBook, MacBook Air, MacBook Pro, Sony, Toshiba

• Apple took 74% of tablet market in Q1

  Counting the iPad, its PC sales grew 187.9% year over year, according to Canalys

  "Canalys today announced that the PC market grew 7% in Q1 2011, as the pad market, led by Apple's iPad, continued to bolster growth."

  That's how Canalys, the first research firm to count tablets as PCs, began its report on how the market shaped up in the first calendar quarter of 2011.

  Thanks to the iPad, Apple (AAPL) jumped MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 28, 2011 7:20 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Apple, Canalys, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, iPad, iPhone, PCs, Personal computer, Tablets

• The triumph of 'good enough' computing

  The global PC market shrank 3.2% year over year in Q1 2011 as iPad sales surged

  It's a pity IDC doesn't include tablets in its quarterly surveys of computer shipments. If it did, the inflection point in the first quarter of 2011 would be even clearer.

  [UPDATE: Asymco's Horace Dediu has done us the favor of drawing an extraordinary graph that includes the iPad. It looks like a giraffe. Click here.]

  IDC had MORE

  Philip Elmer-DeWitt - Apr 13, 2011 8:03 PM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Apple, Asymco, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Horace Dediu, IDC, International Data Corporation, iPad, PCs, Steve Jobs, Tablets, Toshiba

• Here comes the Android tablet price plunge

  Acer's Iconia tablet looks as good as the XOOM on paper and is up for pre-order for $450.

  If you've ever played with an Acer netbook, you'll know the computer maker isn't adept at turning out high end products.  But the Taiwanese company makes a good mid-range product, and they do it with razor-thin margins.  This strategy is part of the reason they canned their CEO Gianfranco Lanci last week, saying MORE

  Seth Weintraub - Apr 8, 2011 10:13 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Android, Best Buy, iPad, MicroSD, Motorola Xoom, Nvidia Tegra, Xoom

• Google closes the book on the CR-48

  You can't get any more CR-48 ChromeOS prototype laptops, but the real things are coming soon.

  In a quick tweet last night, Google's (GOOG) Chrome Lead, Sundar Pichai, Tweeted that Google had run through its supply of the CR-48 laptops.  He also reiterated Google's plans to release partner devices mid-year.  So far, the only partners that have been named are Acer and Samsung.  However, last year, on a number of occasions, HP (HPQ) MORE

  Seth Weintraub - Mar 11, 2011 2:25 PM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Dell, Google, Google Chrome OS, Léo Apotheker, Samsung, Samsung Group, Sundar Pichai

• How Dell conquered India

  The U.S. computer maker got serious in India only a few years ago -- and then proceeded to thrash HP and everyone else. Now India is Dell's fastest-growing market, with 55% growth.

  By Anurag Prasad, contributor

  In the U.S., Dell originally became a market leader through its online and direct made-to-order sales model. When the computer maker decided to enter India, however, it needed a change of strategy.

  In the B.D. era -- MORE

  Feb 10, 2011 8:30 AM ET
  Posted in: Acer, Asia, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, HP, India, Lenovo, PCs