Daily Brainstorm
Google Plus vs. Facebook: not a zero-sum game
January 5, 2012: 1:40 PM ETGoogle Plus is growing fast. How much business it takes away from Facebook will depend -- but it's easy to imagine both thriving and competing with each other for years to come.
By Dan Mitchell, contributor
FORTUNE -- Whenever the subject of traffic or membership on social-media sites comes up, a caveat should be offered: it's really difficult to tell which numbers to believe, if any. Facebook claims 800 million "active users," but I know lots of people -- myself included -- who have more than one account. So, active accounts, maybe. But the number of users is not likely to really be approaching 1 billion of Earth's 6.8 billion inhabitants.
The numbers are even murkier when it comes to Google Plus. Since Google (GOOG) hasn't disclosed its own numbers lately, we must rely on those from outside observers. But the evidence suggests that Google's answer to Facebook is growing fast. Paul Allen, the founder of Ancestry.com who calls himself an "unofficial statistician" for Google Plus, offers an optimistic prediction: that Google Plus will have 400 million users by year's end. Right now, it has just over 60 million, he says. He bases his prediction on his claim that nearly a quarter of all of Google Plus's users signed up in December, indicating a rather breathtaking rate of growth.
Some observers say Google Plus's growth rate is actually higher than that. The last official word from Google itself came in October, when CEO Larry Page said Google Plus had 40 million users. The company didn't give any more information than that, such as how those users were counted: Active monthly users? Did it include people who signed up for the service but have never used it?
But if Google Plus really does reach Allen's estimate for this year, it would turn around what is a troubling trend for the search giant: as a whole, the company is still ahead of everybody in terms of unique visits, but it's being crushed by Facebook in terms of time spent on any given Google property, such as search and YouTube. By that metric, Facebook beats Google, YouTube, Yahoo (YHOO) and AOL (AOL) combined. No wonder Google is putting so much money and effort into social media. Too bad it happened so late.
Still, Google is not easily dismissed. Too often, Google Plus vs. Facebook is presented as a zero-sum game, as if the success of one must result in the downfall of the other. But there's no reason that they can't both thrive, competing with each other (and with Twitter, et al) for users and ad dollars. They share many of the same users now, and that will likely continue to be the case. It's easy to imagine them each claiming different demographics to appeal to different advertisers. Perhaps Google Plus will end up being the network of professionals, techies and creative types, while Facebook continues on as the network of the mainstream. Maybe Google Plus will end up with fewer members and less traffic, but higher CPMs.
Anyway, that's one scenario. One big risk for Facebook in what is fast becoming a real competition is that it will lose more members the more often it creates obnoxious features like the Ticker, carelessly invades users' privacy, or radically revamps the site, as it has done several times recently, culminating in the new Timeline feature. The more friends someone has on Google Plus, and the more features that site adds, the lower the cost to users of switching over from Facebook, or at least of adding Google Plus and going to Facebook less often.
Unless it is careful, Facebook will, if anything, be more prone to muck about with the site once it has billions of dollars of the investing public's money at its disposal after its expected IPO this year. Better Facebook should use the cash to improve service and make deals with more media and gaming companies to add to the site's features. That is, to work on making it more attractive to users rather than less so.
-
Today in Tech: Why Google's former CEO 'screwed up'
Fortune's curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you every day.
"I clearly knew that I had to do something, and I failed to do it ... A CEO should take responsibility. I screwed up." -- Chairman Eric Schmidt on the company's struggle with social. (All Things D)
* During his appearance at All Things D's D9 conference MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - Jun 1, 2011 6:30 AM ET -
Today in Tech: A peek at the Apple iPad factory
Fortune's curated selection of the weekend's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you every day.
A note to readers: Apologies for the lack of updates over the last week -- yours truly was making preparations for a move out West. Effective end of June, I'll report from Fortune's San Francisco offices to better bring readers the latest tech scoops as they break. Thanks MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 23, 2011 6:30 AM ET -
Today in Tech: Steve Ballmer's commencement speech
Fortune's curated selection of the weekend's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you every day.
"If you take even a look at the companies that have succeeded, Microsoft, Apple, Google, Facebook, you name it, all of these companies went through times of hardship. ... And it's how tenacious you are, how irrepressible, how ultimately optimistic and tenacious you are about it that MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 16, 2011 6:30 AM ET -
Today in Tech: Groupon rushing IPO?
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
*All Things D reports that daily deals site Groupon wants that initial public offering (IPO) to happen sooner rather than later -- and by "sooner," we mean as early as this week. Regardless of when ever it does go public though, the company could be valued at $15 billion-plus. MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 11, 2011 6:30 AM ETPosted in: Apple Insider, Farmville, Groupon, Ice Cream Sandwich, Initial public offering, Lady Gaga, Y Combinator -
Today in Tech: Hackers planning third Sony attack?
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
The attacks on Sony's various web servers may not be over. A group of hackers claims it's planning to hit Sony's Web site this weekend and publish a good chunk of the information they steal: possibly customer names, addresses, and credit card numbers. Should that come to pass, MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 6, 2011 6:30 AM ETPosted in: BlackBerry, Caroline McCarthy, Demand Media, Google, Marissa Mayer, Mark Zuckerberg, PlayStation Network, Sony -
Today in Tech: Facebook wants Skype, Cisco reorganizing
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
Facebook and Google are each reportedly negotiating a partnership with Skype, though Facebook is also considering buying the free calling app-maker altogether. Any such deal would hypothetically be valued at between $3 to $4 billion, significantly more than the $1 billion Skype's impending initial public offering (IPO) would MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 5, 2011 11:48 AM ET -
Wojcicki: Advertising, even display, is in Google's DNA
The company's elusive executive isn't just widely respected by employees, but also a force behind many of the products that make the company profitable.
FORTUNE -- Though she's responsible for Google's biggest moneymakers, Susan Wojcicki isn't a recognizable face, certainly not like co-founders Sergey Brin or Larry Page, who rented out her garage in 1998 to serve as Google's (GOOG) first headquarters. But as Senior Vice President of Advertising, her work MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 4, 2011 2:09 PM ET -
Today in Tech: DVD sales drop, streaming services soar
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
Several high-profile Facebook employees have recently left the company, including Jim Midgal, director of business development, Jonathan Heiliger, VP of technical architecture, and Marcel Laverdet, one of three employees who got their jobs by once hacking the social network to resemble MySpace.
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 4, 2011 10:22 AM ET
(Business Insider)
AOL's latest quarterly earnings are in, MORE -
Today in Tech: bin Laden news sets Twitter record, Sony Online hacked, too
A curated selection of the day's most newsworthy tech stories from all over the Web. Sign up to get the newsletter delivered to you everyday.
Research In Motion announced a major update to its smartphone operating system, BlackBerry 7, and the first smartphone to come loaded with it, the BlackBerry Bold 9900/9930, due out some time this summer. The new device sports a 1.2 GHz processor, graphics processing unit (GPU), 768 MB RAM, 2.8-inch touschscreen, 5-megapixel camera MORE
JP Mangalindan, Writer - May 3, 2011 6:30 AM ETPosted in: BlackBerry, Julian Assange, Osama bin Laden, Research in Motion, RIM, Sony Online Entertainment, TweetDeck, Twitter, WikiLeaks, Yahoo
