FORTUNE -- The week before Thanksgiving, roughly 200 Airbnb hosts and community organizers sat shoulder-to-shoulder at The Alley, a Midtown Manhattan co-working space popular with techies. The event was convened by Peers, an organization developed to support the growth of the sharing economy.
An Airbnb host named Mishelle Farer got up to speak. Farer explained how she'd used the money she earned letting out a room in the Williamsburg neighborhood of Brooklyn to fund a public policy degree so that she could launch a career after serving in the military. Now, facing a New York State law that throws Airbnb's practices into question -- people are barred from renting an apartment for fewer than thirty days if a permanent resident of the apartment isn't present -- Farer has turned to Peers.org to launch a petition to clarify it. It has received more than 230,000 signatures so far.
The debate over Airbnb's legality in New York City is shaping up to be the seminal legal dispute for the sharing economy. The stakes have never been higher for the young San Francisco company, and by extension, any of the tech startups that lay claim to a business that supports the sharing economy.
Which is why Airbnb is asking New York State to fix it so that people are allowed to share their homes using Airbnb's service. The company is now sparring with New York State attorney general Eric Schneiderman, who wants to enforce the law. He takes issue with the hosts who run massive numbers of listings and are not required to pay the city's 15% hotel occupancy tax. This fall, he subpoenaed the company for its transaction records for 15,000 New York hosts; Airbnb is fighting to keep that information private to protect its hosts. Meanwhile, the move has had a chilling effect on New York City's 225,000 Airbnb community members, many of whom are understandably concerned about the ramifications of their actions.
Back at The Alley, attendees broke into action teams, segregated by neighborhood, and planned trips to Albany to share their personal Airbnb stories with legislators. Before the legislature convenes in January, New York State senators will likely hear directly from a number of individuals with stories as heartwarming as Farer's.
While it is true that New Yorkers like Farer stand to benefit tremendously from services like Airbnb, all of the rallying around the sharing economy obscures a larger truth: The Internet is disrupting traditional businesses by providing more effective and better designed services. Over the course of history, lawmakers have set up rules and regulations that are designed to help those traditional businesses -- hotels, for example, or taxi services -- operate successfully while keeping consumers safe. As new Internet-enabled businesses like Airbnb and the on-demand driver service Uber are introduced, those laws will need to be reexamined.
This process is already happening across the country. The San Francisco city government has been pressing Airbnb and its hosts to assume responsibility for the same 15% "transient occupancy tax" hotels pay. In Grand Rapids, Mich., the City Commission recently withdrew a proposed ordinance change that would have made advertising on Airbnb a misdemeanor; currently, the city government is studying the issue. The city council in sunny San Luis Obispo this fall legalized home-stays and home rentals of less than 30 days. And that's just Airbnb; Uber's services have similarly been called into question in a number of U.S. cities.
None of these locations has set a precedent for the industry as a whole, but none is as large and as lucrative as New York. A tremendous amount of money hangs in the balance: Revenue from the New York market for Airbnb, hotel tax dollars that the attorney general says Airbnb have been costing the state each year, and of course the fees charged by local New Yorkers to generate a source of income from their overnight guests. The top 40 Airbnb hosts in New York have each grossed at least $400,000 over the past three years, for a total of $35 million.
Schneiderman's concern is that Airbnb can be used as a front for highly profitable illegal businesses that are acting as hotels without paying the taxes or enforcing regulations designed to protect consumers. But Airbnb's Head of Global Public Policy, David Hantman, points out that 90% of Airbnb's hosts have only one listing, and it's for space within their primary residences. The company has said it supports the goal of the 2010 state law, which is to crack down on illegal hotels, and wants to work with Schneiderman to focus on the small subset of hosts using the service this way.
Airbnb also argues that the state should support the service because it is generating a good deal of economic activity for New York City. The company has commissioned an economic study suggesting it has generated $632 million from 419,000 visitors in the state, and more than two-thirds of that sum was money spent on goods and services in outer boroughs, the parts of the city that often don't have hotels.
Meanwhile, Peers has sprung up to influence the conflict through activism. Its volunteers are mostly members of babysitting collectives, car-share services and home-share programs who possess extreme conviction about the role that regular people play in these new business models. Executive Director Natalie Foster explains the group launched in August "with the idea that the sharing economy movement needed a support center." (Foster knows something about how to create movements; she worked at the Sierra Club, MoveOn.org, and on Presidential Obama's digital team.)
But there's one catch: The organization traces its roots to the sharing economy companies that benefit from its activism. Airbnb hired the creative agency Purpose to help brainstorm plans for the organization. Foster says that Peers doesn't take donations from the sharing economy companies, but many of the individuals who are investors in -- and sometimes executives at -- these companies have contributed. Peers has amassed 216,000 members in less than one year.
The New York State judge presiding over the Airbnb case will hear oral arguments in the next month or two. A ruling is expected to be made by January 18.
CEOs reveal what makes an engineer attractive to employers.
FORTUNE -- Great software engineers are hard to find, let alone hire and keep.
Which is why more people than ever are trying to become one. The average annual salary for Google (GOOG) software engineers, for instance, now hovers around $145,000 and skyrockets to as much as $550,000, according to job site Glassdoor.
But training to be a software engineer and snagging a high-profile, high-paying position MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Dec 9, 2013 1:57 PM ET
Studies call their effectiveness into question; now an FDA recall looms.
By Ryan Bradley, senior editor
FORTUNE -- It has not been the best year for Intuitive Surgical (ISRG), the maker of the most popular robot in the world for general surgery, the da Vinci. First, a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found little added benefit to hysterectomies performed with a robot, and yet the procedure MOREDec 9, 2013 1:31 PM ET
The SoMa-based startup, backed by ex-Pixar execs, beefs up its three-month-old interactive app.
FORTUNE -- Before ToyTalk launched its first product this September, a free iPad app called The Winston Show, CEO and founder Oren Jacob expressed some doubt that his startup's vision -- creating a plaything capable of holding in-depth conversations with kids -- would resonate.
"I am confident this will never work in a preschool with 30 kids in it," MOREJP Mangalindan, Writer - Dec 9, 2013 1:16 PM ET
The giant retailer is pushing online and mobile sales. Will the latest cyberpush help America's biggest company reach its e-commerce ambitions?
By Chanelle Bessette, reporter
FORTUNE -- Retailers and analysts have dubbed today "Green Monday," another opportunity (one week after "Cyber Monday" to promote online specials and bolster sales numbers. For retailing giant Wal-Mart (WMT), which says it already has seen record online traffic and sales this holiday season, Green Monday MOREDec 9, 2013 11:31 AM ET
By Dec. 4, the iPhone 5S was available in all 60 U.S. stores surveyed by Piper Jaffray.
FORTUNE -- In early October, two weeks after Apple (AAPL) released the iPhone 5S, the device was out of stock at 92% of the 60 U.S. stores surveyed by Piper Jaffray's Gene Munster.
Piper Jaffray has been checking the stores twice a week ever since, and on Monday Munster announced in a note to clients MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 9, 2013 9:35 AM ET
If so, why has the carrier's website since dropped any mention of Apple's smartphones?
FORTUNE -- Remember Groundhog Day, the 1993 comedy starring Bill Murray as a self-centered TV weatherman who gets stuck in a time loop and must repeat the same hated assignment again and again until he finally gets it right -- and wins Andie MacDowell's heart?
Investors who have been watching Apple's (AAPL) courtship of the world's largest mobile MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 9, 2013 7:52 AM ET
Why, a newspaper asks, was Apple's lawyer paying the doctor's taxes and utilities?
FORTUNE -- Dr. James Eason, the Memphis surgeon who performed Steve Jobs' liver transplant in 2009 -- and later bought the Memphis house where Jobs convalesced -- allowed Apple (AAPL) outside counsel to pay his taxes and utilities for nearly two years.
That revelation came at the end of Southern Transplant, Marc Perrusquia's front page story Thursday in the Memphis Commercial MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 8, 2013 12:46 PM ET
Held to 5 pages by Judge Cote, one critic blasted the DOJ with pictures worth 5,000 words.
FORTUNE -- I missed this legal curio when it was filed back in Sept. 2012 by an amicus curiae (friend of the court) in the case of U.S.A. v. Apple et al. But it caught the eye of both the New York Times' Media Decoder blog and the legal website Above the Law, and MOREPhilip Elmer-DeWitt - Dec 7, 2013 12:36 PM ET
It appears unlikely that Comcast would be able to acquire all of Time Warner Cable. If it makes a bid at all, it would more likely be for just part of the company, with Charter Communications getting the rest.
FORTUNE -- It's not often that an FCC commissioner weighs in on a possible merger in the communications industry. But Ajit Pai did just that in an interview with the Wall Street MOREDan Mitchell, contributor - Dec 6, 2013 2:57 PM ET
|America's economic mobility myth|
|Treasury closes the book on GM bailout with final stock sale|
|Where should you put your money now?|
|The economy: The 2014 outlook|
|Snowden docs had NYTimes exec fearing for his life|